{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","generated_at":"2026-11-02T12:25:30.705Z","record":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","id":"RO-2026-0008","publication_type":"letter","title":"Exponentially Accurate Work Extraction by Swapping Detuned Bosonic Modes","abstract":"A temperature imbalance between two thermal oscillators can yield exponentially little work, even under arbitrary unitary control. We determine when frequency detuning makes a simple mode swap nearly optimal, by bounding the entire extra work available beyond Gaussian operations. With detuning proportional to the temperature bias near equilibrium, this absolute improvement is exponentially small in the inverse bias. The bound separates exponentially weak extraction at resonance from a detuning window with quadratic work, where the swap captures the leading resource. In this limit, within that window, the accessible fraction of the energy excess above a Gibbs state of equal entropy follows a temperature-independent parabola in detuning normalized by the bias. Inside the window, any fixed fraction below 100% of the leading work can be extracted with an occupation cutoff independent of the bias. The finite bound determines when more general control offers negligible additional work.","significance":"An explicit finite thermal-product tail bound controls the improvement over Gaussian work extraction and yields joint-limit consequences for the full unitary optimum. No equivalent result was identified under the bounded NL-3 audit as of 2026-10-14, with MEDIUM confidence; global priority remains unresolved.","limitations":["The central thermal-product claims require finite positive excitation energies and thermal exponents and two bosonic modes.","The asymptotic regime sends relative temperature imbalance epsilon to zero at fixed normalized detuning delta, beta*c and c; fixed nonzero physical mismatch is a different limit.","The entropy-matched Gibbs energy bound, Gaussian identity/swap optimum and swap operating window are established inputs, not new headline claims.","Occupation support is not gate time or power; frequency tuning between preparations and controller cost are outside the fixed-Hamiltonian extraction stroke.","Numerical precision comparisons test arithmetic stability rather than provide directed-rounding interval enclosures or experiments.","The Gaussian extension assumes an independently justified full-rank finite-energy Gaussian-state model; moments alone do not establish the form of arbitrary input states.","All required scientific gates and the independent final Ledger decision support acceptance of C1-C7 within their stated scopes.","The Gaussian residual-energy identity is known; C6 applies the finite bound through that identity. C7 is supporting numerical validation and carries no separate historical-priority assertion."],"state":"PUBLISHED","disposition":"active","visibility":"public","demonstration":false,"created_at":"2026-10-14T22:15:08.112Z","updated_at":"2026-10-15T17:24:09.892Z","program_ids":["PRG-quantum-thermodynamics","PRG-mathematical-physics"],"program_contributions":[{"program_id":"PRG-quantum-thermodynamics","summary":"Quantify extractable work and the additional resource beyond Gaussian operations for thermal bosonic mode pairs under cyclic unitary control."},{"program_id":"PRG-mathematical-physics","summary":"Establish finite spectral-ordering bounds, matching asymptotic exponential rates, and occupation-support formulas with explicit assumptions."}],"problem_ids":[],"taxonomy":{"subject_ids":["subject:quantum-thermodynamics","subject:mathematical-physics"],"method_ids":["method:proof-construction","method:numerical-validation","method:literature-audit","method:independent-reproduction"],"system_ids":[]},"keywords":["ergotropy","Gaussian work extraction","thermal bosonic modes","frequency detuning","passive rearrangement","occupation support"],"licenses":{"manuscript":"CC-BY-4.0","code":"Apache-2.0","data":"CC0-1.0"},"current_version":"v1.0","canonical_url":"https://pudimphysics.org/research/RO-2026-0008","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23401792","paper_preview":{"path":"public/figures/detuning_crossover_preview.png","alt_text":"Two plots of work extraction from detuned thermal oscillator modes. The left plot shows the swap-work fraction approaching a parabola inside the normalized detuning interval from zero to one. The right plot compares an entropy-only estimate with the much smaller finite upper bound on extra work beyond the swap as the inverse temperature bias increases. At inverse bias forty the two upper allowances differ by about one hundred thousand.","caption":"Detuning opens a window where a mode swap captures the leading work. At dimensionless inverse-temperature scale b=1 and normalized detuning delta=1/4, the new finite bound on additional work is about 100,000 times smaller than the entropy-only estimate at temperature bias epsilon=1/40. This compares two upper bounds; the numerical markers are lower estimates of the actual work."},"machine_bundle":{"provider":"zenodo","record_url":"https://zenodo.org/record/23401792","download_url":"https://zenodo.org/records/23401792/files/RO-2026-0008-v1.0.zip?download=1","name":"RO-2026-0008-v1.0.zip","sha256":"dce51701b98e111f1f8f5387571e47c7109f315f00fd770a619a7dc780323a09","bytes":6028682},"creators":[{"name":"Codex (GPT-6 Astra)","role":"Author","kind":"agent","identifier":"codex","version":"0.162.0-alpha.17.2","model":"gpt-6-astra","model_snapshot":null,"provider":"OpenAI","run_started_at":null,"run_completed_at":null,"model_knowledge_cutoff":null,"literature_cutoff":null}],"human_stewards":[{"name":"Domingos S. P. Salazar","role":"Program Manager","kind":"human","identifier":null}],"knowledge_boundaries":{"model_knowledge_cutoff":null,"literature_cutoff":"2026-10-14"},"gates":{"solver":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md"],"actor":"Codex author/orchestrator scientific audit","decided_at":"2026-10-14T22:25:59.468Z","rationale":"Fresh v004 author-side audit rederives the complete headline-claim proof chain and checks C1-C7 scope against the exact candidate. This is a Solver assessment, not an independent novelty, referee, replication or editorial decision.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"novelty_audit":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/literature-audit.yaml","public/paper/reports/LITERATURE_AUDIT.md"],"actor":"Independent context-isolated Ledger Librarian","decided_at":"2026-10-14T22:33:02.757084+00:00","rationale":"Fresh NL-3-bounded primary-literature audit found no equivalent result for the limited finite-bound and full-unitary consequences as of 2026-10-14, with MEDIUM overall confidence. C6 is an application through a known identity; C7 passes framing only. This is not proof correctness, computational validation or global priority.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"adversarial_review":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/review.yaml","public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md"],"actor":"Two context-isolated referees and separate ReviewPRL editor","decided_at":"2026-10-14T22:42:54.414955+00:00","rationale":"Fresh same-candidate round 05: both referees and independent editor ACCEPT/YES with confidence 0.88; no required scientific revisions. Optional presentation and scope notes are preserved, not claimed implemented. This is simulated peer review; reconstruction, final Ledger GO and release authority remain separate.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"independent_reproduction":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/replication.yaml","public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md"],"actor":"Independent two-stage theoretical Replicator","decided_at":"2026-10-14T22:55:17.574002Z","rationale":"Claims C1-C6 independently derived and frozen from statements-only inputs before author proofs were supplied; subsequent source comparison found no unresolved mathematical discrepancy. C7 is explicitly NA for this theoretical role and requires the separate computational gate. All 19 packet inputs and nine exposed source members were verified; the full archive was not independently rehashed by this role.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"computation_reproduction":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/reproduction.json","public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_COMPUTATION_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/PUBLIC_PORTABILITY_REPORT.md"],"actor":"Independent computational Replicator","decided_at":"2026-10-14T23:00:28.141629+00:00","rationale":"All three offline non-root tiers passed within their fixed limits under 2 CPU/2 GiB: complete 55-member archive integrity, scalar checks and full 84-case sorting/ten plot-data comparisons. An independently authored stricter absolute-only decimal-string comparison also passed, and three figures matched text and 200-percent rendered pixels. This is execution and numeric validation, not independent theorem proof or a physical experiment. Prior pre-numerical launch failures are retained.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"formal_verification":{"status":"NA","evidence":["public/replication.yaml"],"actor":"Ledger scope normalization","decided_at":"2026-10-14T23:02:18.492Z","rationale":"No proof-assistant formalization or machine-checked formal proof is claimed. The work supplies analytic proofs, an independent blinded theoretical reconstruction, and computational validation. Formal verification is outside the stated scope; this NA does not weaken the theoretical or computational requirements.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"editorial_gate":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/editorial-decision.yaml","public/paper/reports/FINAL_LEDGER_EDITOR_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/FINAL_LEDGER_EDITOR_VERIFICATION.md"],"actor":"Independent final Pudim Physics Ledger editor","decided_at":"2026-10-14T23:18:34.677605Z","rationale":"The complete Letter and Supplemental Material support C1-C6 through auditable proofs, with an independent statements-only reconstruction frozen before proof comparison. The actual offline non-root execution, full 84-case results and public-source repeat support C7 within its stated numerical scope. The bounded literature audit distinguishes the finite remainder and full-unitary consequences from established inputs. No unresolved scientific blocker was found. Optional presentation notes and final release packaging obligations remain separate from scientific acceptance.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]},"build_provenance":{"status":"PASS","evidence":["public/paper/packaging/LOCAL_BUILD_PROVENANCE.json","public/paper/packaging/PUBLIC_SOURCE_BUILD_CHECK.json","public/paper/packaging/METADATA_EXPORT_CHECK.json","public/paper/reports/PUBLIC_PORTABILITY_REPORT.md","public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_CHECK.json","public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_AUDIT.md"],"actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger publication preparation","decided_at":"2026-10-15T17:18:50.683Z","rationale":"Prior clean build and independent public numerical portability remain valid for unchanged scientific inputs. The independent author-version presentation audit verifies scientific source/text identity, page counts/bookmarks and no reflow. Its strict raster-confinement FAIL is preserved: a sub-0.009-point Letter title-page perturbation affects 2,075 pixels at 144 dpi and is disclosed. This packaging check grants no new scientific verdict.","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","claim_ids":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"]}},"assurance":{"solver":"PASS","novelty_audit":"PASS","adversarial_review":"PASS","independent_reproduction":"PASS","computation_reproduction":"PASS","formal_verification":"NA","editorial_gate":"PASS","build_provenance":"PASS"},"artifacts":{"paper":"public/paper","claims":"public/claims.yaml","proofs":"public/proofs","literature_audit":"public/literature-audit.yaml","review":"public/review.yaml","replication":"public/replication.yaml","reproduction":"public/reproduction.json","editorial_decision":"public/editorial-decision.yaml","provenance":"public/provenance.json","code":"code/public","data":"data/public","figures":"public/figures","release_manifest":"release-manifest.json"},"public_artifacts":["paper","claims","proofs","literature_audit","review","replication","reproduction","editorial_decision","provenance","code","data","figures","release_manifest"],"version_relations":[],"history":[{"at":"2026-10-14T22:15:08.112Z","from":null,"to":"SEED","actor":"Domingos S. P. Salazar","summary":"Private Letter draft initialized for current manuscript revision; imported baseline supplies context only and no canonical gate is inherited.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:26:02.892Z","from":"SEED","to":"PITCHED","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Existing manuscript normalized as a private Letter with explicit purpose, scope and seven proposed claims.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:26:16.786Z","from":"PITCHED","to":"FORAGED","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Primary-literature bibliography and source metadata retained for fresh independent novelty audit; no novelty verdict inherited.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:26:26.455Z","from":"FORAGED","to":"PROGRAM_BUILT","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Final scientific candidate includes complete LaTeX, figures, numerical code/data and document build checks.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:26:38.157Z","from":"PROGRAM_BUILT","to":"CLAIMS_PROPOSED","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Seven atomic claims and their dependencies mapped to exact candidate evidence.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:26:48.046Z","from":"CLAIMS_PROPOSED","to":"SOLVED","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Fresh author-side derivation audit supports all headline claims; independent Ledger gates remain pending.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:34:12.476Z","from":"SOLVED","to":"NOVELTY_LOCK","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Fresh independent NL-3-bounded audit passes the limited v004 novelty scope at MEDIUM confidence; known C6 identity and C7 framing remain explicit.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:34:18.681Z","from":"NOVELTY_LOCK","to":"ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Same-digest scientific packet frozen for two context-isolated referees and a separate editor; prior report conclusions and author diagnostic ratings excluded from the reading allowlist.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T22:44:37.489Z","from":"ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW","to":"REPRODUCTION","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Fresh independent referee/editor round 05 accepts the unchanged v004 candidate with no required revision; proceed to separate blind theory and offline computation reconstruction.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T23:02:20.874Z","from":"REPRODUCTION","to":"EDITORIAL_DECISION","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"Fresh independent theoretical reconstruction and offline computational reproduction pass for the unchanged v004 candidate; final Ledger editorial decision remains unassigned.","evidence":[]},{"at":"2026-10-14T23:19:56.150Z","from":"EDITORIAL_DECISION","to":"ACCEPTED","actor":"Pudim Physics Ledger scientific integration","summary":"The fresh independent final Ledger editor issues GO for C1-C7 on the unchanged v004 candidate, with explicit scope conditions. Scientific acceptance remains private; Program Manager publication authority is null.","evidence":["public/editorial-decision.yaml"]},{"at":"2026-10-15T17:24:09.892Z","from":"ACCEPTED","to":"PUBLISHED","actor":"Pudim AI Ledger Publisher","summary":"Zenodo registered 10.5281/zenodo.23401792; the exact v1.0 release is now public.","evidence":["release-manifest.json","public/editorial-decision.yaml"]}],"claims":[{"id":"C1","type":"theorem","headline":true,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"For H=a*n_h+c*n_c and rho=tau_x tensor tau_y, with a,c,x,y>0, let e_-=min(a,c), e_+=max(a,c), q=min(x,y), D=|x-y|, C=(1-exp(-x))(1-exp(-y)), and K=floor(min(e_-/(e_+-e_-),q/D)), treating a zero denominator as infinity. Then 0<=W-W_G<=C*e_+*sum_{N=K+1}^infinity N(N+1)exp(-q*N), including energy/population ties. If both denominators vanish, the state is Gibbs and W=W_G=0.","assumptions":["Two thermal bosonic modes with finite positive thermal exponents and excitation energies.","W optimizes cyclic arbitrary unitaries and W_G optimizes Gaussian unitaries for the same fixed Hamiltonian."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"external_result","id":"Brown2016","record_id":null},{"kind":"external_result","id":"Quintela2025","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"apparently_new","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Find positive a,c,x,y for which independently computed ergotropy exceeds the stated analytic bound.","Audit passive ordering within and between retained shells and the infinite-dimensional tail limit, including ties."],"superseded_by":null},{"id":"C2","type":"corollary","headline":true,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"For beta_h=beta*(1-epsilon), beta_c=beta*(1+epsilon), a/c=1+2*delta*epsilon/(1-epsilon), fixed b=beta*c>0, c>0 and real delta, as epsilon tends to zero through physical positive frequencies, 0<=W-W_G=O_{b,c,delta}(epsilon^(-2)*exp(-b/(2*max(delta,1-delta)*epsilon))).","assumptions":["epsilon is relative temperature imbalance, not stroke time.","The limit fixes delta, b and c; it does not fix nonzero physical frequency mismatch."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"claim","id":"C1","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"apparently_new","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Reconstruct K asymptotics and the finite geometric tail independently.","Check the exponential bound at interior, edge and exterior detunings without exchanging the prescribed limits."],"superseded_by":null},{"id":"C3","type":"corollary","headline":true,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"For the same family, with B the initial energy excess above the Gibbs state of equal entropy, lim_{epsilon->0} W/B equals 4*delta*(1-delta) for 0<delta<1 and zero for delta<=0 or delta>=1.","assumptions":["Same thermal-product and fixed-parameter assumptions as C2.","B is the entropy-matched Gibbs bound, not initial energy."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"claim","id":"C2","record_id":null},{"kind":"external_result","id":"Alicki2013","record_id":null},{"kind":"external_result","id":"Sacchi2021","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"apparently_new","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Independently expand swap work and entropy matching to quadratic order.","Test normalized sorting results across the two window edges and interior."],"superseded_by":null},{"id":"C4","type":"theorem","headline":true,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"At fixed delta outside the open interval (0,1), the same family satisfies lim_{epsilon->0} epsilon*log(W/c)=-b/(2*max(delta,1-delta)); this logarithmic rate includes both endpoints and asserts no prefactor asymptotic.","assumptions":["Same assumptions as C2.","Positive two-state swaps supply the lower construction; the upper bound alone is insufficient."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"claim","id":"C2","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"apparently_new","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Independently construct positive-work occupation swaps on each side and at each endpoint.","Check that an extra integer step removes arbitrarily small tie prefactors without altering the logarithmic rate."],"superseded_by":null},{"id":"C5","type":"theorem","headline":false,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"For controls acting only on m+n<=M and as identity outside, the least resonance cutoff permitting positive work is floor((1-epsilon)/(2*epsilon))+2; inside 0<delta<1 the least cutoff is one. At fixed M and interior fixed delta, lim W_M/W=(1-z)^4*sum_{N=1}^M binomial(N+2,3)*z^(N-1), z=exp(-b), so any fixed fraction below one uses a bias-independent cutoff.","assumptions":["Same family and limit as C2.","Cutoff describes supported occupations and is not a time, power or Gaussian-control resource claim."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"claim","id":"C3","record_id":null},{"kind":"external_result","id":"Brown2016","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"apparently_new","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Enumerate small truncated spectra and check minimal activation cutoff including equality cases.","Reconstruct shellwise restricted sorting and the finite-sum fraction independently."],"superseded_by":null},{"id":"C6","type":"corollary","headline":false,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"For full-rank finite-energy two-mode Gaussian states, Gaussian passification to a thermal product sigma_G yields W(rho)-W_G(rho)=W(sigma_G); C1 then bounds this non-Gaussian advantage because W_G(sigma_G)=0.","assumptions":["The input Gaussian-state model is independently justified.","The selected Gaussian passification attains the Gaussian optimum and preserves the unitary spectrum."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"claim","id":"C1","record_id":null},{"kind":"external_result","id":"Brown2016","record_id":null},{"kind":"external_result","id":"Quintela2025","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"known","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Verify the Gaussian normal form and passive-energy invariance with explicit displaced, squeezed and correlated examples.","Check that no inference for arbitrary states from covariance alone has been introduced."],"superseded_by":null},{"id":"C7","type":"computational_result","headline":false,"lifecycle":"established","statement":"The supplied 84-case passive-ordering sweep and repeated high-precision arithmetic comparisons check the declared finite models and asymptotic regimes; analytic omitted-energy bounds, not agreement of floating-point runs alone, control spectral truncation.","assumptions":["Finite parameter grid and declared arithmetic precision/tolerances.","No new hardware experiment or directed-rounding interval enclosure is claimed."],"dependencies":[{"kind":"claim","id":"C1","record_id":null},{"kind":"claim","id":"C3","record_id":null},{"kind":"claim","id":"C4","record_id":null},{"kind":"claim","id":"C5","record_id":null}],"evidence":[{"kind":"source","path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","status":"complete"},{"kind":"computation","path":"data/public/pc2_results.json","status":"complete"},{"kind":"proof","path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/review.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/replication.yaml","status":"complete"},{"kind":"source","path":"public/reproduction.json","status":"complete"}],"novelty_status":"known","review_status":"passed","reproduction_status":"passed","falsification_tests":["Independently regenerate declared outputs from final code/data and compare within predeclared scientific tolerances.","Inspect cases with unresolved tiny remainders and confirm that captions preserve the distinction from resolved total work."],"superseded_by":null}],"literature_audit":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","accepted_claims":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"],"search_cutoff":"2026-10-14","auditor":"Independent Ledger Librarian","sources":["https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05399","https://arxiv.org/pdf/1211.1209","https://arxiv.org/html/2502.17409v2"],"queries":["ergotropy Gaussian states Brown Friis Huber 2016 work extraction 113028","Quintela Rodriguez 2503.21748 Gaussian ergotropy thermal states","bosonic thermal machines Sacchi 2021 swap engine ergotropy","\"Passivity and practical work extraction\" arxiv","\"Entanglement boost for extractable work\" Alicki Fannes 2013","\"Bosonic two-stroke heat engines with polynomial nonlinear coupling\" arxiv","ergotropy thermal oscillators \"exponentially\" detuning","\"ergotropy\" \"passive\" \"shell\" bosonic","\"ergotropy\" \"exponentially small\" thermal","\"ergotropy\" \"4\" \"detuning\" Gaussian","\"work extraction\" \"occupation cutoff\" thermal","ergotropy \"N(N+1)\" thermal","ergotropy Gaussian \"q/D\" bound","\"work extraction\" thermal \"4\" \"delta(1\" ","\"thermal\" \"ergotropy\" \"activation\" cutoff","\"ergotropy\" \"exp\" \"temperature difference\" oscillators","\"thermal modes\" \"non-Gaussian\" \"bound\" ergotropy","\"ergotropy\" \"binomial\" cutoff","\"work\" \"Gaussian\" \"4δ\"","\"ergotropy\" \"N(N+1)\"","\"ergotropy\" \"epsilon\" \"exponential\"","\"thermal\" \"work extraction\" \"binomial(N+2\"","\"bosonic\" \"passivity\" \"near equilibrium\""],"inclusions":[{"citation":"Eric G. Brown, Nicolai Friis, and Marcus Huber, Passivity and practical work extraction using Gaussian operations, New Journal of Physics 18, 113028 (2016).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","verified":true},{"citation":"Frank Ernesto Quintela Rodriguez, Francesco Anna Mele, Salvatore Francesco Emanuele Oliviero, Vittorio Giovannetti, Ludovico Lami, and Vasco Cavina, Extracting energy via bosonic Gaussian operations, arXiv:2503.21748v1 (2025).","identifier":"arXiv:2503.21748v1","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","verified":true},{"citation":"Massimiliano F. Sacchi, Thermodynamic uncertainty relations for bosonic Otto engines, Physical Review E 103, 012111 (2021).","identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.103.012111","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05399","verified":true},{"citation":"Robert Alicki and Mark Fannes, Entanglement boost for extractable work from ensembles of quantum batteries, Physical Review E 87, 042123 (2013).","identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.87.042123","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1211.1209","verified":true},{"citation":"Giovanni Chesi, Chiara Macchiavello, and Massimiliano Federico Sacchi, Bosonic two-stroke heat engines with polynomial nonlinear coupling, Quantum Science and Technology 10, 035012 (2025).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/2058-9565/adcd98","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2502.17409v2","verified":true}],"exclusions":[{"identifier":"doi:10.1103/43jm-qkz2","reason":"Screened primary search result: continuous-variable entanglement/relative ergotropic-gap scope. Not a thermal-product shell-tail or joint detuning-bias theorem. Its broad Gaussian/full-ergotropy equality wording is not used as a premise; the audited sources distinguish those optima."},{"identifier":"doi:10.1038/s41467-017-01505-4","reason":"Screened primary result concerns catalytic activation/reversible operations with an additional machine, rather than the specified isolated two-mode unitary orbit; not inspected as a sixth decisive work."},{"identifier":"doi:10.1038/s42005-023-01439-y","reason":"Screened primary result concerns a driven battery's dynamics and drive detuning, rather than two thermal modes with a fixed extraction Hamiltonian."},{"identifier":"https://pure.mpg.de/rest/items/item_3167176_1/component/file_3167220/content","reason":"Screened primary repository result concerns suppression of work fluctuations with the number of copies; its exponential parameter and task differ from the inverse-temperature-bias remainder."},{"identifier":"Secondary aggregators, ResearchGate mirrors, review summaries, unrelated formula matches","reason":"Discovery only; not relied upon for any novelty conclusion or bibliographic verification."}],"claim_assessments":[{"claim_id":"C1","closest_work":[{"citation":"Eric G. Brown, Nicolai Friis, and Marcus Huber, Passivity and practical work extraction using Gaussian operations, New Journal of Physics 18, 113028 (2016).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","verified":true},{"citation":"Frank Ernesto Quintela Rodriguez, Francesco Anna Mele, Salvatore Francesco Emanuele Oliviero, Vittorio Giovannetti, Ludovico Lami, and Vasco Cavina, Extracting energy via bosonic Gaussian operations, arXiv:2503.21748v1 (2025).","identifier":"arXiv:2503.21748v1","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","verified":true}],"delta":"PASS for the explicit finite, tie-inclusive bound Ce_+ sum_{N>K} N(N+1)e^{-qN}, with K=floor(min(e_-/(e_+-e_-),q/|x-y|)), on the full-unitary advantage over the Gaussian optimum for a specified thermal product. The Gaussian optimum and passive rearrangement are established ingredients. The candidate adds the simultaneous energy/population shell-prefix criterion and a computable residual tail estimate; no equivalent result was identified under the recorded NL-3-bounded search.","unresolved_equivalences":["A more general spectral-rearrangement or near-Gibbs stability theorem might imply a comparable bound; this bounded search does not settle every such historical equivalence.","Exact-formula web search has poor coverage of equations embedded in PDFs; negative results do not establish priority."],"confidence":"MEDIUM","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C2","closest_work":[{"citation":"Eric G. Brown, Nicolai Friis, and Marcus Huber, Passivity and practical work extraction using Gaussian operations, New Journal of Physics 18, 113028 (2016).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","verified":true},{"citation":"Frank Ernesto Quintela Rodriguez, Francesco Anna Mele, Salvatore Francesco Emanuele Oliviero, Vittorio Giovannetti, Ludovico Lami, and Vasco Cavina, Extracting energy via bosonic Gaussian operations, arXiv:2503.21748v1 (2025).","identifier":"arXiv:2503.21748v1","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","verified":true},{"citation":"Giovanni Chesi, Chiara Macchiavello, and Massimiliano Federico Sacchi, Bosonic two-stroke heat engines with polynomial nonlinear coupling, Quantum Science and Technology 10, 035012 (2025).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/2058-9565/adcd98","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2502.17409v2","verified":true}],"delta":"PASS as a corollary of C1 for a specific joint limit: fixed b,c,delta and epsilon down to zero, with detuning proportional to bias. The delta-dependent absolute remainder O(epsilon^{-2} exp(-b/[2 max(delta,1-delta) epsilon])) is the defensible addition. It is not an original Gaussian protocol, a fixed-frequency-mismatch theorem, or an exact interior rate.","unresolved_equivalences":["No comprehensive survey of all near-equilibrium passivity asymptotics was possible within the five-work bound; independent equivalence to a general flatness theorem remains open."],"confidence":"MEDIUM","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C3","closest_work":[{"citation":"Massimiliano F. Sacchi, Thermodynamic uncertainty relations for bosonic Otto engines, Physical Review E 103, 012111 (2021).","identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.103.012111","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05399","verified":true},{"citation":"Robert Alicki and Mark Fannes, Entanglement boost for extractable work from ensembles of quantum batteries, Physical Review E 87, 042123 (2013).","identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.87.042123","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1211.1209","verified":true},{"citation":"Frank Ernesto Quintela Rodriguez, Francesco Anna Mele, Salvatore Francesco Emanuele Oliviero, Vittorio Giovannetti, Ludovico Lami, and Vasco Cavina, Extracting energy via bosonic Gaussian operations, arXiv:2503.21748v1 (2025).","identifier":"arXiv:2503.21748v1","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","verified":true}],"delta":"PASS only for the limiting fraction of the full arbitrary-unitary ergotropy relative to the equal-entropy Gibbs bound, obtained through C1/C2. The swap work, its window, the Gibbs bound, and the leading Gaussian parabola are established or elementary consequences. The claim upgrades the Gaussian ratio to W/B and fixes its exterior value to zero; novelty does not lie in naming a parabola or in the denominator itself.","unresolved_equivalences":["A pre-existing expansion of the Gaussian ratio may equal 4 delta(1-delta); that would not remove the full-unitary conclusion unless accompanied by control of the non-Gaussian remainder."],"confidence":"MEDIUM","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C4","closest_work":[{"citation":"Eric G. Brown, Nicolai Friis, and Marcus Huber, Passivity and practical work extraction using Gaussian operations, New Journal of Physics 18, 113028 (2016).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","verified":true},{"citation":"Giovanni Chesi, Chiara Macchiavello, and Massimiliano Federico Sacchi, Bosonic two-stroke heat engines with polynomial nonlinear coupling, Quantum Science and Technology 10, 035012 (2025).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/2058-9565/adcd98","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2502.17409v2","verified":true}],"delta":"PASS for the matching logarithmic rate of the unrestricted optimum outside the open swap window, including both endpoints. High-occupation activation and nonlinear extraction beyond the swap window are not new. The delta-dependent sharp exponential scale, backed by upper and lower constructions and with no prefactor claim, is the defensible delta.","unresolved_equivalences":["Earlier activation constructions could contain a latent lower exponential scale; no equivalent two-sided unrestricted rate was identified in the five decisive works.","No verdict is offered about an exact prefactor or an interior rate for W-W_G."],"confidence":"MEDIUM","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C5","closest_work":[{"citation":"Eric G. Brown, Nicolai Friis, and Marcus Huber, Passivity and practical work extraction using Gaussian operations, New Journal of Physics 18, 113028 (2016).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","verified":true},{"citation":"Massimiliano F. Sacchi, Thermodynamic uncertainty relations for bosonic Otto engines, Physical Review E 103, 012111 (2021).","identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.103.012111","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05399","verified":true}],"delta":"PASS as a supporting quantitative refinement: the exact least resonance occupation cutoff, plus the fixed-M captured-work fraction (1-z)^4 sum_{N=1}^M binomial(N+2,3) z^{N-1}. Inverse-bias high-occupation activation is established. The finite sum is a standard negative-binomial cumulative expression; novelty is its identification with this restricted-work fraction and comparison with the full optimum, not a new combinatorial identity.","unresolved_equivalences":["The exact integer cutoff is close to elementary passivity/inversion criteria and may have appeared in a more specialized source not recovered by this bounded search.","The claim establishes occupation support only; time, power, experimental control cost, and Gaussian implementation are outside the assessed delta."],"confidence":"MEDIUM","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C6","closest_work":[{"citation":"Eric G. Brown, Nicolai Friis, and Marcus Huber, Passivity and practical work extraction using Gaussian operations, New Journal of Physics 18, 113028 (2016).","identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","verified":true},{"citation":"Frank Ernesto Quintela Rodriguez, Francesco Anna Mele, Salvatore Francesco Emanuele Oliviero, Vittorio Giovannetti, Ludovico Lami, and Vasco Cavina, Extracting energy via bosonic Gaussian operations, arXiv:2503.21748v1 (2025).","identifier":"arXiv:2503.21748v1","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","verified":true}],"delta":"PASS only as an application of C1 to full-rank finite-energy Gaussian inputs. The Gaussian normal form and the identity W(rho)-W_G(rho)=W(sigma_G) are established/elementary; the residual-energy identity is explicitly equivalent to Quintela Rodriguez et al. Eq. (78) on a Gaussian unitary orbit. The new content is substitution into C1. An independent-priority claim for this identity would FAIL.","unresolved_equivalences":["There is no unresolved priority claim for the identity: it is treated as known. The application inherits C1's bounded-search uncertainty.","Pure Williamson modes and arbitrary non-Gaussian states sharing the covariance are excluded."],"confidence":"MEDIUM","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C7","closest_work":[],"delta":"PASS for novelty framing only: the stated 84-case finite-model sweep is supporting numerical validation, not a claim of a new historical theorem or experiment. This audit did not rerun code, inspect numerical outputs, verify precision, or grant the computational/reproduction gate.","unresolved_equivalences":["Computational validity and truncation control remain for independent computation/reproduction assessment; PASS here grants no such validation."],"confidence":"HIGH","outcome":"PASS"}],"overall_outcome":"PASS"},"review":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","accepted_claims":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"],"rounds":[{"round":5,"candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","opened_at":"2026-10-14T22:34:16.930Z","closed_at":"2026-10-14T22:42:54.414955+00:00","referees":[{"id":"R1","context_isolated":true,"report_path":"public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1.md","recommendation":"ACCEPT","confidence":0.88,"verification_scope":"Complete Letter/SM proof and code inspection; selected independent Decimal/Fraction arithmetic and activation/support checks; three primary works. No full 84-case rerun or complete raster review."},{"id":"R2","context_isolated":true,"report_path":"public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2.md","recommendation":"ACCEPT","confidence":0.88,"verification_scope":"Complete Letter/SM and rendered pages/figures; exact packet/member hashes; independent scalar and direct-rank checks, five sorting cases and all stored-row arithmetic; four primary works. No full 84-case rerun, all-figure regeneration, TeX rebuild or experiment."}],"editor":{"independent_context":true,"decision":"ACCEPT","confidence":0.88,"letter_path":"public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md","decisive_evidence":["public/paper/reports/EDITOR_VERIFICATION.md","public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1.md","public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1_VERIFICATION_LOG.md","public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2.md","public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2_VERIFICATION.md"]},"findings":[{"id":"F-R5-001","criterion":"Scope and significance; source findings R1-003 and R2-001","severity":"note","affected_claims":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"],"finding":"The ideal two-mode thermal/Gaussian setting and coordinated near-equilibrium limit restrict breadth. Robustness to preparation error, anharmonicity, growing arrays, tuning cost and dynamical control cost are not established. A compact significance sentence was suggested optionally.","evidence":["public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1.md","public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2.md","public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md"],"response":"The author retains the stated scope limitations and the editor judges them compatible with Letter acceptance. No broader robustness, cost or experimental claim is added.","resolution":"accepted"},{"id":"F-R5-002","criterion":"Title qualification; source finding R1-004","severity":"note","affected_claims":["C2","C3"],"finding":"Optional addition of near-equilibrium wording to the title would make the asymptotic setting visible immediately.","evidence":["public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1.md","public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md"],"response":"Accepted as an optional nonblocking note. The editor required no revision; the candidate remains unchanged and this suggestion is not represented as implemented. Existing abstract and fixed-parameter definitions state the regime.","resolution":"accepted"},{"id":"F-R5-003","criterion":"Interior exponent clarification; source finding R1-005","severity":"note","affected_claims":["C2","C4"],"finding":"Optionally recall near the first remainder formula that the interior exponent is an upper estimate; matching rates are proved only outside the window.","evidence":["public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1.md","public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md"],"response":"Accepted as an optional nonblocking note. The editor required no revision; the candidate remains unchanged and this suggestion is not represented as implemented. The displayed inequalities and supplement already distinguish the two claims.","resolution":"accepted"},{"id":"F-R5-004","criterion":"Figure 1(a) ordinate; source finding R2-002","severity":"note","affected_claims":["C3","C7"],"finding":"A generic Work fraction ordinate would cover both Gaussian swap curves and unrestricted-work markers; the existing legend and caption already distinguish them.","evidence":["public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2.md","public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md"],"response":"Accepted as an optional nonblocking note. The editor required no revision; the candidate remains unchanged and this suggestion is not represented as implemented. The author retains the existing legend and caption identification.","resolution":"accepted"},{"id":"F-R5-005","criterion":"Entropy-relaxation reference; source finding R2-003","severity":"note","affected_claims":["C1","C7"],"finding":"A pinpoint citation could clarify that the plotted gray allowance is the entropy-only relaxation and does not evaluate every bound containing passive-state information in Ref. 22.","evidence":["public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2.md","public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md"],"response":"Accepted as an optional nonblocking note. The editor required no revision; the candidate remains unchanged and this suggestion is not represented as implemented. The caption explicitly defines the entropy-only allowance B-W_G; no claim to surpass every prior bound is added.","resolution":"accepted"}],"author_response":{"actor":"Codex author/orchestrator","path":"public/paper/reports/AUTHOR_RESPONSE.md","submitted_at":"2026-10-14T22:42:54.414955+00:00"},"revision_digest":null,"outcome":"PASS"}],"ledger_decision":{"decision":"GO","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","authority":"Independent ReviewPRL editor, round 05; adversarial-review scope only","decided_at":"2026-10-14T22:42:54.414955+00:00","rationale":"Both isolated referees and the separate editor accept this exact candidate, each at confidence 0.88, with no required revision. Optional notes remain accepted without implementation. This review-stage GO permits reconstruction; final independent Ledger editorial assessment and release authority are separate stages."}},"replication":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","replicator":"Independent theoretical Replicator","independent_of":["solver","reviewer","publisher"],"started_at":"2026-10-14T22:46:52Z","completed_at":"2026-10-14T22:55:17.574002Z","claim_results":[{"claim_id":"C1","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/paper/tex/references.bib","https://arxiv.org/html/1608.04977v2","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1110.3234v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1211.1209v2"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"PASS: independently derived countable passive ordering with finite-rank projections, Gaussian shell alignment, simultaneous shell separation through K, and tail-energy bound. Compared with the author summation-by-parts and prefix proof, including attainability, finite energy, ties, zero denominators, and arbitrary positive frequencies. No unresolved discrepancy.","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C2","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/paper/tex/references.bib","https://arxiv.org/html/1608.04977v2","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1110.3234v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1211.1209v2"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"PASS: independently substituted the physical family, derived K=1/(2 L epsilon)+O(1), controlled qK and the geometric quadratic tail, and recovered the stated absolute exponential upper bound. Author steps and endpoint conventions agree after direct algebraic checks; fixed-parameter scope retained.","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C3","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/paper/tex/references.bib","https://arxiv.org/html/1608.04977v2","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1110.3234v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1211.1209v2"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"PASS: independently differentiated entropy matching along the full physical path and expanded the exact thermal relative entropy, obtaining the stated B coefficient. Verified Gaussian work signs and coefficients, division by positive quadratic B, and exact square-root Gibbs-producing swap. Author Hessian route was checked against this pathwise derivation; no domain gap remains from the cited finite-dimensional source.","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C4","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/paper/tex/references.bib","https://arxiv.org/html/1608.04977v2","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1110.3234v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1211.1209v2"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"PASS: independently constructed strict positive swaps on both exterior branches using a two-step floor offset, established polynomial gap factors and the matching exponential lower scale, then combined with C2. Author integer pairs are algebraically identical after index translation; both endpoints and strict positive work were checked. No prefactor equivalence claimed.","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C5","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/paper/tex/references.bib","https://arxiv.org/html/1608.04977v2","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1110.3234v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1211.1209v2"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"PASS: independently derived the strict resonance cutoff from extreme populations in adjacent shells and the interior one-excitation onset. Reconstructed the exact fixed-M shell reversal, finite binomial coefficient, limiting ratio and generating function. Checked the author finite inversion criterion and asymptotic quantifiers. No time, power or Gaussian-implementation implication used.","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C6","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/paper/tex/references.bib","https://arxiv.org/html/1608.04977v2","https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1110.3234v1","https://arxiv.org/html/1211.1209v2"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"PASS: independently derived passive-energy orbit invariance and Gaussian-work subtraction. Verified primary Gaussian minimum and thermal normal-form dependencies, finite covariance, full-rank exclusion of a pure Williamson mode, finite positive exponents, and C1 applicability. The author explicitly preserves the Gaussian model restriction and pure-mode exclusion.","outcome":"PASS"},{"claim_id":"C7","mode":"theoretical","blinded_to_solver_proof_initially":true,"inputs":["public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","public/claims.yaml","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json"],"artifacts":["public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json"],"environment":"Analytic two-stage reconstruction. Python 3.11.9 and jsonschema 4.26.0 used only for metadata, hashes and schema checks; no numerical reproduction.","commands":[],"tolerances":[],"comparison":"NA: this run is theoretical. The 84-case sweep, numerical environment, code execution, repeated arithmetic comparisons and reported numerical outputs were not reproduced. No computational PASS is implied by the analytic checks of C1-C6.","outcome":"NA"}],"overall_outcome":"PASS"},"reproduction":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","accepted_claims":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"],"entrypoint":"code/public/reconstruction/run_offline.py","container":{"image":"sha256:cc6dbfdd040582433b5f7e698206a9ae612dfd0d19d178d7563ae87f8b654acb","digest":"sha256:cc6dbfdd040582433b5f7e698206a9ae612dfd0d19d178d7563ae87f8b654acb","lockfiles":["code/public/reconstruction/requirements-lock.txt"]},"offline":true,"non_root":true,"reference_runner":{"os":"linux","vcpus":8,"memory_gb":8},"tiers":[{"tier":0,"description":"Public 32-member scientific subset hash, byte lengths, safe paths and CRC; all public members map exactly to the accepted full candidate.","maximum_seconds":120,"commands":["python3 code/public/reconstruction/run_offline.py --archive public/paper/scientific-source-v004.zip --manifest public/paper/scientific-source-manifest-v004.json --output new-public-tier0 --image ro0008-numerical:local --tier 0"],"outcome":"PASS"},{"tier":1,"description":"Independent 100-digit scalar formulas for 84 cases, geometric tail, entropy root, support fraction and integer activation checks.","maximum_seconds":300,"commands":["python3 code/public/reconstruction/run_offline.py --archive public/paper/scientific-source-v004.zip --manifest public/paper/scientific-source-manifest-v004.json --output new-public-tier1 --image ro0008-numerical:local --tier 1"],"outcome":"PASS"},{"tier":2,"description":"Full 84-case integer passive-sort rerun and all scientific plot JSON comparisons, plus three-figure regeneration.","maximum_seconds":1200,"commands":["python3 code/public/reconstruction/run_offline.py --archive public/paper/scientific-source-v004.zip --manifest public/paper/scientific-source-manifest-v004.json --output new-public-tier2 --image ro0008-numerical:local --tier 2"],"outcome":"PASS"}],"expected_outputs":[{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier0/tier0.json","kind":"data","comparison":"semantic","expected_sha256":"c0a68acf68ea645c0d42f02e8f3034f1289d071c29e6ee466082f794be563c0e"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier1/tier1.json","kind":"data","comparison":"semantic","expected_sha256":"e746f4e0cb8ef5645e16ad654545a441d68976ca5de14763e2d55edde00cf7a0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/control_support.pdf","kind":"figure","comparison":"existence","expected_sha256":"757c3068e77aaf859f2718613141bbaa485ed00c0f40dce0d1a639ed0789effa"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/control_support_preview.png","kind":"figure","comparison":"existence","expected_sha256":"5e0e09e0ea956f923f0065b60a4809093923a86413caea9c777b188d21b6293c"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/detuning_crossover.pdf","kind":"figure","comparison":"existence","expected_sha256":"0ca7f363ef852ac0f7be4d97f410fb32c1900f1d948b9621a8b5701c753212e0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/detuning_crossover_preview.png","kind":"figure","comparison":"existence","expected_sha256":"4fbbc26f93637ce399623a760279e2bac26192bb37a6b19c1bc3155de5129b91"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/exterior_rates.pdf","kind":"figure","comparison":"existence","expected_sha256":"77ad2d83985cdcbcd64a7ba1e938db948c90a451d56453e59512ae0e52146b8d"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/exterior_rates_preview.png","kind":"figure","comparison":"existence","expected_sha256":"9f2d7e99c72cc8b9f8a374f52b4e1546d0fc3345115ddaf386f2a2e81205f1da"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/computation-logs/tier2/plot-regeneration.log","kind":"log","comparison":"semantic","expected_sha256":"240e8a920a99407f4f7d43a873118b43856dda8affef0e1ee047309072c43625"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier2/sorting/results.json","kind":"data","comparison":"tolerance","expected_sha256":"bdcc13c91d960d8d08296f5458433b340fa47b03cb42c2f9a908105fcd452918"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/computation-logs/tier2/sorting.log","kind":"log","comparison":"semantic","expected_sha256":"045b76a8628c48cb39fc61165bd4d3392551d6d149028298a713f142f7fe9b29"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier2/tier2.json","kind":"data","comparison":"semantic","expected_sha256":"e0adaa0220c8a1d76b4ec60f7e6693bf3698d9006b76af80dedfb9f599352a65"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/public-execution.json","kind":"data","comparison":"semantic","expected_sha256":"df12f2014656b0959d23547b57b9b2a3949c7f014549448cb1ec1a8bcf1dbf9f"}],"scientific_tolerances":[{"output":"tier2/sorting/results.json","metric":"Exact integer fields and 84 parameter combinations","tolerance":"Exact match for parameters, swap, cutoff, state count, rate groups and nonzero groups."},{"output":"tier2/sorting/results.json","metric":"Gaussian work, remainder, omitted-tail bound and reconstructed total","tolerance":"Relative 1e-65 plus absolute 1e-145; reconstruct total from high-precision components."},{"output":"tier2/tier2.json","metric":"All scientific plot JSON numeric leaves","tolerance":"JSON numbers: relative 1e-11 plus absolute 1e-13; decimal strings: relative 1e-11 plus absolute 1e-75."}],"attestation":{"run_path":"public/paper/reports/public-execution.json","image_digest":"sha256:cc6dbfdd040582433b5f7e698206a9ae612dfd0d19d178d7563ae87f8b654acb","lock_hashes":{"code/public/reconstruction/requirements-lock.txt":"fff30bcc87b7c8fc9e8ad2da8b6bcb4f7db55680d491cb45a9788189237efa76"},"started_at":"2026-10-14T20:01:07.7296-03:00","completed_at":"2026-10-14T20:02:11.127818-03:00","resources":{"cpus":2,"memory_gib":2,"tmpfs_gib":1,"network":"none","uid":65532,"root_filesystem":"read-only","tested_environment":"Rootless Podman inside WSL Linux","public_archive_sha256":"750b879fc258fed5445268526b681b92e7a0c097aba8048b81230b1a2f611432","full_candidate_archive_mounted":false,"new_image_recipe_built":false,"scope":"Additional independent public-subset execution; primary candidate-bound machine report is retained separately. The candidate digest names accepted science, while public archive_sha256 names packaging.","tier_measurements":[{"tier":0,"status":"PASS","elapsed_seconds":0.0210239879997971,"maximum_seconds":120,"exit_code":0,"uid":65532,"peak_rss_kib":26116,"child_peak_rss_kib":0},{"tier":1,"status":"PASS","elapsed_seconds":4.82141054900012,"maximum_seconds":300,"exit_code":0,"uid":65532,"peak_rss_kib":26840,"child_peak_rss_kib":0},{"tier":2,"status":"PASS","elapsed_seconds":45.259578801000316,"maximum_seconds":1200,"exit_code":0,"uid":65532,"peak_rss_kib":27988,"child_peak_rss_kib":100936}],"recommended_command_scope":"Tier commands are reusable instructions after building the supplied dependency-only recipe as ro0008-numerical:local; each uses a separate empty output directory. The actual historical commands and cached image ID are retained in public/paper/reports/public-execution.json. The new recipe was not executed in this check."},"exit_codes":{"tier_0":0,"tier_1":0,"tier_2":0},"output_hashes":{"data/public/reconstruction/tier0/tier0.json":"c0a68acf68ea645c0d42f02e8f3034f1289d071c29e6ee466082f794be563c0e","data/public/reconstruction/tier1/tier1.json":"e746f4e0cb8ef5645e16ad654545a441d68976ca5de14763e2d55edde00cf7a0","public/figures/reproduced/control_support.pdf":"757c3068e77aaf859f2718613141bbaa485ed00c0f40dce0d1a639ed0789effa","public/figures/reproduced/control_support_preview.png":"5e0e09e0ea956f923f0065b60a4809093923a86413caea9c777b188d21b6293c","public/figures/reproduced/detuning_crossover.pdf":"0ca7f363ef852ac0f7be4d97f410fb32c1900f1d948b9621a8b5701c753212e0","public/figures/reproduced/detuning_crossover_preview.png":"4fbbc26f93637ce399623a760279e2bac26192bb37a6b19c1bc3155de5129b91","public/figures/reproduced/exterior_rates.pdf":"77ad2d83985cdcbcd64a7ba1e938db948c90a451d56453e59512ae0e52146b8d","public/figures/reproduced/exterior_rates_preview.png":"9f2d7e99c72cc8b9f8a374f52b4e1546d0fc3345115ddaf386f2a2e81205f1da","public/paper/reports/computation-logs/tier2/plot-regeneration.log":"240e8a920a99407f4f7d43a873118b43856dda8affef0e1ee047309072c43625","data/public/reconstruction/tier2/sorting/results.json":"bdcc13c91d960d8d08296f5458433b340fa47b03cb42c2f9a908105fcd452918","public/paper/reports/computation-logs/tier2/sorting.log":"045b76a8628c48cb39fc61165bd4d3392551d6d149028298a713f142f7fe9b29","data/public/reconstruction/tier2/tier2.json":"e0adaa0220c8a1d76b4ec60f7e6693bf3698d9006b76af80dedfb9f599352a65","public/paper/reports/public-execution.json":"df12f2014656b0959d23547b57b9b2a3949c7f014549448cb1ec1a8bcf1dbf9f"},"gate_results":[{"id":"public_subset_integrity","outcome":"PASS"},{"id":"public_scalar_audit","outcome":"PASS"},{"id":"public_full_regeneration","outcome":"PASS"},{"id":"public_source_equivalence","outcome":"PASS"}]},"overall_outcome":"PASS"},"editorial_decision":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","ledger_decision":{"decision":"GO","authority":"Independent final Pudim Physics Ledger editor (Codex)","decided_at":"2026-10-14T23:18:34.677605Z","rationale":"The complete Letter and Supplemental Material support C1-C6 through auditable proofs, with an independent statements-only reconstruction frozen before proof comparison. The actual offline non-root execution, full 84-case results and public-source repeat support C7 within its stated numerical scope. The bounded literature audit distinguishes the finite remainder and full-unitary consequences from established inputs. No unresolved scientific blocker was found. Optional presentation notes and final release packaging obligations remain separate from scientific acceptance."},"pm_release_authorization":{"authorized":true,"name":"Domingos S. P. Salazar","role":"Program Manager","authorized_at":"2026-10-15T17:10:31.819Z","rationale":"The Program Manager explicitly instructed publication of the accepted paper to PudimPhysics with the verified Codex version. Recorded at the current UTC time; the exact user-message timestamp is not asserted."},"accepted_claims":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"],"evidence":["public/claims.yaml","public/paper/tex/letter.tex","public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","public/literature-audit.yaml","public/paper/reports/LITERATURE_AUDIT.md","public/review.yaml","public/replication.yaml","public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","public/reproduction.json","public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_COMPUTATION_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/public-portability.json","public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/packaging/METADATA_EXPORT_CHECK.json","public/paper/reports/FINAL_LEDGER_EDITOR_REPORT.md","public/paper/reports/FINAL_LEDGER_EDITOR_VERIFICATION.md","public/paper/packaging/PUBLICATION_AUTHORIZATION.json"],"blocking_findings_disposition":["No unresolved scientific blocking finding. Required proof, novelty, adversarial review, independent theory and computational gates have substantive same-candidate evidence.","F-R5-001 (R1-003/R2-001): accepted as a nonblocking scope/significance limitation; no robustness, preparation-error, growing-array, tuning-cost or dynamical-cost result is inferred.","F-R5-002 (R1-004): optional title qualification remains unimplemented; the abstract and definitions already delimit the near-equilibrium scaling.","F-R5-003 (R1-005): optional main-text reminder remains unimplemented; interior residual upper bounds are distinct from matched exterior logarithmic rates.","F-R5-004 (R2-002): optional generic Figure 1(a) ordinate remains unimplemented; caption and legend identify swap curves and unrestricted-work markers.","F-R5-005 (R2-003): optional entropy-relaxation pinpoint remains unimplemented; the plotted allowance is explicitly B-W_G and no claim about all prior passive-state bounds is made.","The two recorded host-launch failures occurred before numerical assertions; they do not invalidate the subsequent successful, bound Linux execution and remain preserved.","Public build-command punctuation and auxiliary-file/path descriptions require final release-layout reconciliation. These are publication-packaging obligations, not scientific blockers; later repairs were not inspected by this editor."],"conditions":["Scientific GO is bound to the stated full-candidate digest and frozen 181-input packet; it is neither an APS decision nor authorization for a DOI, upload, deployment or other external release.","C1 requires two thermal bosonic modes with finite positive excitation energies and thermal exponents. C2-C5 use fixed b,c,delta as epsilon tends to zero through physical frequencies; no fixed nonzero mismatch or growing-mode limit is accepted.","C2 bounds an absolute remainder. Relative near-optimality applies in the open swap window; C4 establishes exterior logarithmic rates, including both endpoints, without a prefactor claim or matching interior remainder rate.","C3 uses the entropy-matched Gibbs energy excess, not initial energy. C5 concerns occupation support, not time, power, control cost or general Gaussian implementation of a supported swap.","C6 applies C1 through established Gaussian passification and unitary-orbit invariance; no novelty claim for that identity, covariance-only conclusion for arbitrary states or pure Williamson-mode extension is accepted.","C7 is finite deterministic validation. Analytic omitted-energy bounds control spectral truncation; high-precision agreement does not provide directed-rounding bounds. Some tiny residuals remain unresolved relative to their tails. No physical experiment or independent full sorting reimplementation is claimed.","Novelty is bounded by the recorded five-work, 23-query audit as of 2026-10-14 at MEDIUM confidence. No absolute historical-priority claim is approved.","Preserve the separate identities and mappings of the full candidate, public source ZIP and metadata-only combined PDF. Keep Codex as scientific author, Domingos S. P. Salazar separately as Program Manager, and unknown exact model/snapshot fields null.","Before publication, verify public commands and links in the actual release layout, preserve raw role evidence, finalize build provenance, mandatory allowlist, release manifest and the matching preview with caption/alt text, and obtain actual human Program Manager authorization bound to this candidate. The supplied new dependency recipe was not rebuilt and does not promise the historical cached image identity."]},"provenance":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","agents":[{"name":"Codex (GPT-6 Astra)","role":"Author","identifier":"codex","version":"0.162.0-alpha.17.2","model":"gpt-6-astra","model_snapshot":null,"provider":"OpenAI","model_knowledge_cutoff":null,"literature_cutoff":null}],"task_specifications":[],"tools":[{"name":"Research Ledger OS","version":"0.2.0","scientific_purpose":"Maintain claim-level evidence and immutable stage inputs."},{"name":"Research Ledger Publisher","version":"0.2.0","scientific_purpose":"Prepare attributed, hashed scientific artifacts and preserve release boundaries."},{"name":"ReviewPRL","version":null,"scientific_purpose":"Two isolated referees and a separate editor assessed the same candidate."}],"sources":[{"identifier":"doi:10.1088/1367-2630/18/11/113028","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04977","accessed_at":"2026-10-14"},{"identifier":"arXiv:2503.21748v1","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2503.21748v1","accessed_at":"2026-10-14"},{"identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.103.012111","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05399","accessed_at":"2026-10-14"},{"identifier":"doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.87.042123","url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1211.1209","accessed_at":"2026-10-14"},{"identifier":"doi:10.1088/2058-9565/adcd98","url":"https://arxiv.org/html/2502.17409v2","accessed_at":"2026-10-14"}],"environments":["Numerical reconstruction used Python 3.12.3, numpy 2.2.6, scipy 1.17.0, matplotlib 3.10.8 and mpmath 1.3.0 under offline rootless Podman with 2 CPU and 2 GiB memory limits.","The tested cached image cc6dbfdd040582433b5f7e698206a9ae612dfd0d19d178d7563ae87f8b654acb retains unused historical assets. All executed RO0008 scientific inputs and runner paths are explicitly mounted. The supplied new Containerfile builds a dependency-only image."],"datasets":["data/public/pc2_results.json","data/public/plot_detuning_curves.json","data/public/plot_control_support.json"],"random_seeds":[],"material_artifacts":["public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","public/paper/PRL_Letter.pdf","public/paper/Supplemental_Material.pdf","public/paper/scientific-source-v004.zip","public/literature-audit.yaml","public/review.yaml","public/replication.yaml","public/paper/packaging/METADATA_EXPORT_CHECK.json","public/paper/packaging/PUBLIC_SOURCE_BUILD_CHECK.json","code/public/reconstruction/runner-origin.json","public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_VERSION_PROVENANCE.json","public/paper/packaging/PUBLICATION_AUTHORIZATION.json","public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_CHECK.json","public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_AUDIT.md","code/public/packaging/apply_author_version.py"],"disclosures":{"private_chain_of_thought_preserved":false,"secrets_included":false,"notes":["Program Manager: Domingos S. P. Salazar, recorded separately from scientific authorship.","No Oracle was used.","The immutable full candidate archive and 32-member public source ZIP preserve accepted bytes. Displayed PDFs and two public TeX files are explicitly mapped attribution derivatives with unchanged science and a quantified small Letter title-page raster perturbation. SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json and AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_CHECK.json describe the distinction.","Readable public role reports use role labels and omit local paths. Original reports and raw search output remain in the private audit archive.","The review is a simulation under PRL-level scientific standards and is not an APS decision.","The author/orchestrator revision session recorded model gpt-6-astra and Codex CLI/runtime version 0.162.0-alpha.17.2 at session creation on 2026-10-14. The publication turn on 2026-10-15 also recorded gpt-6-astra. No immutable model snapshot or model knowledge cutoff is recorded. This attribution concerns the revision and integration session for the accepted paper, not the upstream imported draft or independent review roles.","The recorded version 0.162.0-alpha.17.2 is the Codex CLI/runtime value at authoring-session creation, not a desktop package version or immutable model snapshot.","The Program Manager explicitly authorized publication. Registration and public-release identity are recorded only through the production publication transaction."]}},"release_manifest":{"protocol_version":"0.2.0","record_id":"RO-2026-0008","release":"v1.0","candidate_digest":"b3c9edee77241ad6f0cbb4e3d108d730c17f8f75c08a628e219da3300ce68bd4","accepted_claims":["C1","C2","C3","C4","C5","C6","C7"],"created_at":"2026-10-15T17:18:50.000Z","git_commit":"da281bf0aecebdf0cf13db78df6506febc670dd5","build":{"builder":"research-ledger-publisher/0.2.0","reproducible":true,"source_date_epoch":1792084730},"files":[{"path":"citation.bbl","sha256":"5999070e1942dd92783d045b9f08981a6d19385ae9d485b7f182afa38f4372e9","bytes":308,"media_type":"application/x-tex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"citation.bib","sha256":"7aa397674db7cf7212a7390a1563acab3f7e89855c2adaa09d8bf604e32bf354","bytes":1432,"media_type":"application/x-bibtex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"CITATION.cff","sha256":"5824caaa86dc823c57fe43fb688147a01f324dadc8c66fb2a536cf13ca7b72af","bytes":1952,"media_type":"application/yaml","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"citation.csl.json","sha256":"bee9c6b59c9a53aba30b52422e5440aa9551c2cbb87d696588c77cc785863d68","bytes":1553,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"code/public/manuscript/build_paper.py","sha256":"a9fa17ce45005eb26dc88d35fd4ad813e0bd42bd882534bd866e21d736ed024b","bytes":2838,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/manuscript/build_references.py","sha256":"9047130c38c0cfa92a30d5a88ac2e9cdea5fc28e140afb98d32c750ecda53095","bytes":2051,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/manuscript/detuning_sort.py","sha256":"e2de1e44823d3c55be6cb7602024f71ce4508cfad082644eb3a2b97fff96bf64","bytes":4663,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/manuscript/package_pdfs.py","sha256":"7a1f5d27e415b6dccb94dd7c58b0dacf40ba68711c2a5b2635176703b46bf6d1","bytes":1307,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/manuscript/plot_detuning.py","sha256":"85885df1b24a73422bd5ccabcf45b5d9d8006819b26e1b935f182ab6522d2f31","bytes":25182,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/packaging/apply_author_version.py","sha256":"c997779895577ca50535795f859120a7116cbc5c800df8aea7daf815d4bb6666","bytes":3189,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/packaging/normalize_combined_metadata.py","sha256":"1137edc34972949c37899022872e16d5dd59345ba18bf12f2b26a8fe2f76cb32","bytes":3428,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/packaging/README.md","sha256":"93b5bf4b6cd537d304bc8b5262a8f603be8f4929b7508686344d561357023793","bytes":370,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/reconstruction/Containerfile","sha256":"e450d21ce1dd0d52c55e0883e052e045fb0081aa9e4eb959fa607a56f187ea16","bytes":340,"media_type":"application/octet-stream","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/reconstruction/README.md","sha256":"3d364c75f4bd27ad039c0d5e376fd8b9c02a029aa39dd60294daf2ec1459611f","bytes":4034,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/reconstruction/reproduce.py","sha256":"4b3a99ea0b7a302e57d5e9c360cc3bf3be1a8197013fbcb6244f1920d3b839aa","bytes":17645,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/reconstruction/requirements-lock.txt","sha256":"fff30bcc87b7c8fc9e8ad2da8b6bcb4f7db55680d491cb45a9788189237efa76","bytes":144,"media_type":"text/plain","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/reconstruction/run_offline.py","sha256":"098d804a98eef4912fdbe779757ea182ab9ea17858034b32a62d748004e92815","bytes":5366,"media_type":"text/x-python","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"code/public/reconstruction/runner-origin.json","sha256":"4cf4fb8fa7966b5af886a7ecbb44ee94a9ec29de16eef24cc60a326a73d02a9e","bytes":1148,"media_type":"application/json","license":"Apache-2.0"},{"path":"data/public/pc2_results.json","sha256":"43d2acb3b35c3ccc889f7205fe0b6d9d6360c4bef9382b113d4760484366f76e","bytes":63997,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_activation_cutoffs.json","sha256":"66391c2fc3ad125c48d73da506469d0435555d308c608f23b2daac57a36019e0","bytes":175258,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_audit_cases.json","sha256":"7a99b19d06d4332e822d3e824631b4998b513066f01add305dae891b9fafcbc5","bytes":164937,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_captions.json","sha256":"b1a6f0bd7004df35c5165a2e5aeb71a817f198fbb94c7528485dc53140eb0ee3","bytes":2091,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_capture_thresholds.json","sha256":"957db4721a2dd523f1f35834ed37def294c31121d3f33563ff7fea0346122b50","bytes":1484,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_control_support.json","sha256":"7652ed2fd3eac99c7701ac7423751717f1830ac8047200aa066e35313530fb74","bytes":47682,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_detuning_curves.json","sha256":"3922a9a22ba98e6356b004e9024882e3d1d5b1599ca7af2d5ae16718f9563582","bytes":163741,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_finite_M_coefficient_checks.json","sha256":"999a4b5481bb0338550d92151e565d72c204a6f4d0c4f74e4b5790bb557cf7a3","bytes":32696,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_gibbs_saturation_checks.json","sha256":"8dc8800970bd1ffa4cf6602f3632e474d569e2068d0ef8e6891bd2c5d291c348","bytes":3804,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_rate_guides.json","sha256":"81b038fe7cf53b5725755301b3cb0748a7539d046d0febf333e4b296282ba548","bytes":816,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_remainder_comparison_markers.json","sha256":"ec34cab268962b3f19f95c148a764231d9eb0b5469768791f98c68bd4b95f69d","bytes":1143,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/plot_remainder_comparison.json","sha256":"0f40a42b9e461bd5638c2c3f2275cb180b4a12d4595a18420edd0f714736045d","bytes":190932,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/strict-plot-comparison.json","sha256":"f1c3e168a0b273c04c4ce7df8c0545afc09a1e6298f56e6405110e47a39e82c6","bytes":5782,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier0/tier0.json","sha256":"c0a68acf68ea645c0d42f02e8f3034f1289d071c29e6ee466082f794be563c0e","bytes":6611,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier1/tier1.json","sha256":"e746f4e0cb8ef5645e16ad654545a441d68976ca5de14763e2d55edde00cf7a0","bytes":72714,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier2/sorting/results.json","sha256":"bdcc13c91d960d8d08296f5458433b340fa47b03cb42c2f9a908105fcd452918","bytes":70212,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"data/public/reconstruction/tier2/tier2.json","sha256":"e0adaa0220c8a1d76b4ec60f7e6693bf3698d9006b76af80dedfb9f599352a65","bytes":35988,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"public/claims.yaml","sha256":"725ee8e72429a63250d9d9763de62da0c6f0bbacf42a0fb9bc8f5eabc298cbb2","bytes":12103,"media_type":"application/yaml","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/editorial-decision.yaml","sha256":"0569f3de57a2a169f53ab192d26a02b6ee1f77040d097c391a58ed21eaeef825","bytes":5875,"media_type":"application/yaml","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/control_support_preview.png","sha256":"dad8a564bf3fdcc027e526d3af8f84035988d7d4ceac20c2a363c06d0918d593","bytes":76649,"media_type":"image/png","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/control_support.pdf","sha256":"757c3068e77aaf859f2718613141bbaa485ed00c0f40dce0d1a639ed0789effa","bytes":17301,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/detuning_crossover_preview.png","sha256":"ed5b3dfb95de598fc6a7238430f4409f01993bf4bb34519982c8d22dbec5b892","bytes":156289,"media_type":"image/png","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/detuning_crossover.pdf","sha256":"a5c727148d4a1a47c77d2a3cf982a2a7670e8ab3180b658bc15fa73395276751","bytes":34298,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/exterior_rates_preview.png","sha256":"27a6590ad2861e2328ccf74c0f52350d05d10a8ce7f90c5e948e0dd51ca4694d","bytes":77540,"media_type":"image/png","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/exterior_rates.pdf","sha256":"5fa42e5f4a2de8009cf21bf4a7676f879057ef8866513c61ae29fd5a5da2797b","bytes":15407,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/control_support_preview.png","sha256":"5e0e09e0ea956f923f0065b60a4809093923a86413caea9c777b188d21b6293c","bytes":82027,"media_type":"image/png","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/control_support.pdf","sha256":"757c3068e77aaf859f2718613141bbaa485ed00c0f40dce0d1a639ed0789effa","bytes":17301,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/detuning_crossover_preview.png","sha256":"4fbbc26f93637ce399623a760279e2bac26192bb37a6b19c1bc3155de5129b91","bytes":164588,"media_type":"image/png","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/detuning_crossover.pdf","sha256":"0ca7f363ef852ac0f7be4d97f410fb32c1900f1d948b9621a8b5701c753212e0","bytes":34300,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/exterior_rates_preview.png","sha256":"9f2d7e99c72cc8b9f8a374f52b4e1546d0fc3345115ddaf386f2a2e81205f1da","bytes":81992,"media_type":"image/png","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/figures/reproduced/exterior_rates.pdf","sha256":"77ad2d83985cdcbcd64a7ba1e938db948c90a451d56453e59512ae0e52146b8d","bytes":15409,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/literature-audit.yaml","sha256":"f267f0228b449a0a1b7c8db576451e63e12780ab3cf0f2c0e6e68b8d8644fe46","bytes":14590,"media_type":"application/yaml","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/article.pdf","sha256":"81e44b07a81466cb6108de6d38eeb1f7d455a2f6a1858ca7a8053372807915ad","bytes":424516,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/combined.pdf","sha256":"6b195f9554a200ec4978a8945b2b3969205b9ced02561941e27b60bc27002b8f","bytes":736482,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/LICENSES.md","sha256":"61b6c8df3baab03f8d8044b57d91a9c5f8f2b10aa3bd4b4aa546f5ebd4c84c8e","bytes":418,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_AUDIT.md","sha256":"57a71ae3c492033b440ac407dcaf720e8e4cfc3186e7a997326334a67c6588b2","bytes":5606,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_ATTRIBUTION_CHECK.json","sha256":"39b4e6b59095496788436b6d94dd260ae893b9f66937855abd14d86c925e0899","bytes":4707,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/AUTHOR_VERSION_PROVENANCE.json","sha256":"5ed56074b19e956f6829b057035e3f268cfce84c8063a64839e7334d4818c5bb","bytes":2296,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/LOCAL_BUILD_PROVENANCE.json","sha256":"017d7d33163b642ee50f8648d7457e414f6159322a37ab4b0922222f470383de","bytes":2665,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/METADATA_EXPORT_CHECK.json","sha256":"35456a5649b8777e2df8b1680340cb94811ea87aea3beda90f565fb2faf21414","bytes":2549,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/PUBLIC_SOURCE_BUILD_CHECK.json","sha256":"de5c8cb7eea86aab90e922b47308b8c2d6f1c4b73ecc947e4ca2951352e7b5a5","bytes":797,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/packaging/PUBLICATION_AUTHORIZATION.json","sha256":"6115c2a2ed02891d2e87f95b161480791ae776f37bbc29d25c612238edfc2aa2","bytes":517,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/PRL_Draft_with_Supplement.pdf","sha256":"6b195f9554a200ec4978a8945b2b3969205b9ced02561941e27b60bc27002b8f","bytes":736482,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/PRL_Letter.pdf","sha256":"81e44b07a81466cb6108de6d38eeb1f7d455a2f6a1858ca7a8053372807915ad","bytes":424516,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/README.md","sha256":"72c96f19d861569b597f1468c79d6318411a166b8bac9800b26627732e6b3aeb","bytes":4870,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/AUTHOR_RESPONSE.md","sha256":"2cacf6a7c507408e4ffd89f51dee337a63e505e14ae839af7b32f6cf363c37a4","bytes":1404,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/computation-logs/tier2/plot-regeneration.log","sha256":"240e8a920a99407f4f7d43a873118b43856dda8affef0e1ee047309072c43625","bytes":746,"media_type":"application/octet-stream","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/computation-logs/tier2/sorting.log","sha256":"045b76a8628c48cb39fc61165bd4d3392551d6d149028298a713f142f7fe9b29","bytes":28629,"media_type":"application/octet-stream","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/computational-visual-qa.json","sha256":"1939ec55c64fe112d1d29d64140861d989dd3ce9984fbe6542b7d107fe716524","bytes":3306,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/EDITOR_DECISION.md","sha256":"725e7021894e20f19efbf7857220200bf7046087c7ad20db8faee6b9fdbf8ea5","bytes":5427,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/EDITOR_VERIFICATION.md","sha256":"a8b106acd9ffaa945d37ed0e1e0a5c9f0400ea791f124f6b9c5d7e7088a02b5c","bytes":3490,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/FINAL_LEDGER_EDITOR_REPORT.md","sha256":"eae317aefb2368467a644db52741a367ee5210849be84bf82f234258db4152b9","bytes":14340,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/FINAL_LEDGER_EDITOR_VERIFICATION.md","sha256":"4ac2202e6bbcb8ea281554919b62139df1f9a18be37f6a3be8fa2ad0aa740a07","bytes":7083,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_COMPUTATION_REPORT.md","sha256":"dc44242abf5c2b4b7acbecb4ec9d8160f4bfc9f41dbd8f04d72049621d8f805b","bytes":4623,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/INDEPENDENT_THEORY_REPORT.md","sha256":"34d3b72e2460f3668a8a9ee24c0c5492022fc13bff4faa19ce4c46d6d2288449","bytes":14163,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/LITERATURE_AUDIT.md","sha256":"853b450fe668c84a7ec1b1f874157748db7f974bcadb4aada62602cfd9054826","bytes":12611,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/PUBLIC_PORTABILITY_REPORT.md","sha256":"3d536eb94386cb833c867adcf24694df27799e780d7615f8355147c587cf8fae","bytes":2528,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/public-execution.json","sha256":"df12f2014656b0959d23547b57b9b2a3949c7f014549448cb1ec1a8bcf1dbf9f","bytes":7074,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/public-portability.json","sha256":"e180478c71129248c8f3c02ea5f54cf19cfd8f8ab9ce6351e2e5ed69bf7ec2a4","bytes":6299,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1_VERIFICATION_LOG.md","sha256":"0fe7e1ce82ac58b3f8789ca48ee3e8e2989c1bb8fd4c566c88978f48326698a2","bytes":5132,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/REFEREE_1.md","sha256":"20fa5b8e49ba9819ebde618cb9288f7b249f7e8f552aaee5f9f77d094c86b0b2","bytes":6742,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2_VERIFICATION.md","sha256":"3876ec4a10ebcdf562419853640f2b34fa49c954ccb428846495df438fe59a8d","bytes":7529,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/REFEREE_2.md","sha256":"c46bb6e3827902619980f3aa35fde9a11d9c99affcd72c1421cfab4a49913606","bytes":7249,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/reports/theory-proof-comparison.json","sha256":"99dc8387b25856e1cf457540abaf59ae35ae3dcbe8bcaccd91f0661053d14690","bytes":4345,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/requirements.txt","sha256":"06f29dea2716ccb284329d846975e508f3a5e5e5b7c1c0533a9b6a28e14577e1","bytes":72,"media_type":"text/plain","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/SCIENTIFIC_SOURCE_MAP.json","sha256":"e092d48084c816866ec12595556097f4fc5d4135f53781191febceb97201e02e","bytes":13525,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/scientific-source-manifest-v004.json","sha256":"ba519745c67d915508818bbf12048b085df89f07334cb00d5182e85b8f412a6b","bytes":5783,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/scientific-source-v004.zip","sha256":"750b879fc258fed5445268526b681b92e7a0c097aba8048b81230b1a2f611432","bytes":601331,"media_type":"application/zip","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/sources/bibliography_metadata.csv","sha256":"5da67db6139e61dd3de2eb1e86e2a1fe56853253df20fa0fb885ecc6823e8498","bytes":10910,"media_type":"text/csv","license":"CC0-1.0"},{"path":"public/paper/supplement.pdf","sha256":"a53f51e6d97972b542f7a43a1dda99561ef001de10f4b57ea5040390f7180af3","bytes":410893,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/Supplemental_Material.pdf","sha256":"a53f51e6d97972b542f7a43a1dda99561ef001de10f4b57ea5040390f7180af3","bytes":410893,"media_type":"application/pdf","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/letter.bbl","sha256":"0ab7b51f74c2e4d827379306e4207bfddb938cdaf5e899fe1c93857979309310","bytes":10936,"media_type":"application/x-tex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/letter.tex","sha256":"7441c7452483a01133b9519d2ee6855432290117843fde1d57b2ff6c0bf1621e","bytes":22343,"media_type":"application/x-tex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/letterNotes.bib","sha256":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","bytes":0,"media_type":"application/x-bibtex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/references.bib","sha256":"e388a1c3bc5b366b1bbc6b29a755338c9f148620f323be5d2272663524e16b7c","bytes":13857,"media_type":"application/x-bibtex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.bbl","sha256":"853b0c79f6042f24195f6d304f7a635380d7e78c5c304683f0532f24af3af825","bytes":2013,"media_type":"application/x-tex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/supplement.tex","sha256":"295ef18d522fa06e043923dc7c84b6fe0541b01c536792d7415820edfbc68594","bytes":24643,"media_type":"application/x-tex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/tex/supplementNotes.bib","sha256":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","bytes":0,"media_type":"application/x-bibtex","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/paper/VERSION_NOTES.md","sha256":"fc3eca87e65a82e26c8f712662fddb373914822aac2d272c9d4b56dc77c3fe72","bytes":1641,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/proofs/AUTHOR_DERIVATION_AUDIT.md","sha256":"3d768379ebdc5b63b19e2de49a7e286e9a32bc6fad2d6770d71166fe4a334830","bytes":6196,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/proofs/THEORY_STATEMENTS.md","sha256":"a8ebe9c69064ca087486a33e1b22afedd4c4e4986a4bf04c33b7fc80053070ba","bytes":6509,"media_type":"text/markdown","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/provenance.json","sha256":"5625217320944972906c7d70033eca58b5a6c93d96e00192913c3ccc246e4903","bytes":5148,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/replication.yaml","sha256":"825b807b476fd3d9a3c01f336837f0d3afbbccc6e817d9c3cd85297b6f6da7d2","bytes":8710,"media_type":"application/yaml","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/reproduction.json","sha256":"c526da779cd0046e9aa55db0e81ca7c75d4c5203287207c007aad02681d4e59f","bytes":10432,"media_type":"application/json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"public/review.yaml","sha256":"e5501748b5bc9c13e92c039fd5e633a15cc25fbc53561f3ff6d26e1c1fc59091","bytes":6524,"media_type":"application/yaml","license":"CC-BY-4.0"},{"path":"schema.org.jsonld","sha256":"ff81a0eb056972a6b370877076b06a87312dd5a1f78187e0b295d9c225de6b0b","bytes":2040,"media_type":"application/ld+json","license":"CC-BY-4.0"}],"release_digest":"ce57bd953af07110e40d070e268bd258111147ce77bae0d2bfa55b48f505241e","bundle_hashes":{"data":"f98f88ef8437a1e730ccf3f421ff948f1b4af8a81718ba1ff00ad0f09a341184"},"gates":{"solver":"PASS","novelty_audit":"PASS","adversarial_review":"PASS","independent_reproduction":"PASS","computation_reproduction":"PASS","formal_verification":"NA","editorial_gate":"PASS","build_provenance":"PASS"},"public_artifacts":["claims","code","data","editorial_decision","figures","literature_audit","paper","proofs","provenance","release_manifest","replication","reproduction","review"],"doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23401792"}}}