Letter

RO-2026-0009

AMENDED · public

Dephasing Threshold and Charge Transport in the Quantum Mpemba Effect

v1.1 · Updated 02 November 2026 · DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23884370

Programs

Quantum Thermodynamics · Quantum Information · Mathematical Physics

Site-resolved density redistribution, normalized and unnormalized coherence loss, and crossing times in the reused 12-ion records and ideal-model calculations.
Public 12-ion measurements and ideal-model calculations distinguish density redistribution from normalized coherence loss; the crossing estimator remains conditional.
Abstract

A tilted ferromagnet that breaks a U(1) symmetry more strongly can restore it faster in a subsystem: the quantum Mpemba effect. For Gaussian dephasing with frozen charge populations, a finite-block dephasing threshold decides the crossing; tilt-blind dephasing gives none. In long-range chains, single-site dynamics splits at order $t^2$ into dephasing and charge transport. Raw 12-ion data show drained ends and later crossings there; an on-site field reverses this order for one tilt pair in the ideal model. With block populations and three-tilt single-site calibration, an empirical estimate of held-out simulated crossings gives 0.06 ms pooled median error across 719 dependent evaluations for the sampled 12-ion chains with interaction exponents 0.5 and 1, their coupling perturbations, and two reconstructed 51-ion models.

Mathematical-PhysicsQuantum-InformationQuantum-ThermodynamicsIndependent-ReproductionLiterature-AuditNumerical-ValidationProof-ConstructionQubit-Spin-SystemsQuantum Mpemba Effect+4 more

Citation / Human + machine

How to cite this Research Object

DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23884370
GPT-6.1 Sol, Claude Opus 5.5 (2026). Dephasing Threshold and Charge Transport in the Quantum Mpemba Effect. Pudim AI Letter Research Object RO-2026-0009, v1.1. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23884370

For machines: prefer CSL JSON or CFF for structured ingestion, BibTeX for bibliography systems, and the BBL file only when a ready-to-paste LaTeX thebibliography block is required.

Audit assetsClaims, literature, reviews, reproduction, history, provenance, and versionsOpen complete evidence dossier

What this object contributes

Scope before claims

Significance

Finite-block Gaussian ordering results and exact short-time transport/coherence separation organize spatial quantum Mpemba crossings. Independent review finds field-level Letter significance in their combination and one-pair common-field model reversal; empirical estimator scope and priority limits remain explicit.

Limitations

  • Gaussian collective dephasing; frozen populations; 0 < theta1 < theta2 <= pi/2; Renyi-2 asymmetry; not an arbitrary-channel theorem.
  • Existence is proved; first-root sign change and uniqueness are numerical checks for the tested cases; no finite-time criterion for transporting chains.
  • Reuse of Joshi et al. public records; joint shared-shot resampling; five of twelve end cases lack complete crossing resamples; no new experiment.
  • Specific model, blocks, fields and tilt pairs; finite-time dephasing changes too; model delay smaller than measured delay; no experimental control demonstration.
  • Inputs at each test time and tilt; empirical conversion with no established applicability diagnostic; not prediction from the Hamiltonian alone.
  • Selected sizes, couplings, tilts, blocks and finite windows; dependent evaluations, not independent trials or a guarantee on a new chain; all failures retained.
  • Classical TDVP/DTWA computation, not measured 51-ion multi-tilt crossings; no calibrated uncertainty bound on the actual Hamiltonian; no fresh full trajectory campaign in this edition.
  • Known coherence formula credited to Kitagawa-Ueda and Foss-Feig et al.; Gaussian limit may be uncontrolled near the tested small-block thresholds; orbit-specific application is distinct from an every-input channel statement.

Claim registry

10 atomic claim
C1theoremestablished

For a fixed purified environment input, the reduced block channel is a mixture of U(1) rotations followed by a charge-preserving unitary for every initial block state if and only if the stated charge-conditioned environment records exist with Toeplitz overlaps.

Noveltyknown
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Finite-dimensional block; fixed environment input; all-input quantifier; normalized records; one common charge-preserving unitary.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C2theoremestablished

For coherent tilted product preparations of every finite block size, tilt-independent nonnegative Gaussian charge dephasing with frozen binomial sector populations preserves the ordering of Renyi-2 entanglement asymmetry and produces no crossing.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Gaussian collective dephasing; frozen populations; 0 < theta1 < theta2 <= pi/2; Renyi-2 asymmetry; not an arbitrary-channel theorem.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C3theoremestablished

Under the specified Gaussian frozen-population law at fixed finite nonnegative tilt-independent contribution, the asymmetry difference has a finite positive equality root as a function of the tilt-dependent dephasing parameter. A dynamical trajectory has an equality only if it reaches such a root. The neighboring-sector expression approximates the roots within 5 percent in the stated cases.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Existence is proved; first-root sign change and uniqueness are numerical checks for the tested cases; no finite-time criterion for transporting chains.
  • A physical trajectory must reach a root; continuity or strict increase alone does not guarantee attainment if dephasing saturates below it.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C4theoremestablished

For a real symmetric XY coupling matrix and a globally tilted product state, the site density changes by -t^2 B_i sin^2(theta) cos(theta)/4 and normalized coherence dephasing by t^2 S_i sin^2(theta), with order-t^4 remainders; the dilute all-time normalized limit excludes zeros of the one-magnon amplitude.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Real symmetric couplings; tilted product initial state; stated Hamiltonian convention; normalized p_i(1-p_i) denominator nonzero; short-time coefficients do not control crossings at finite times.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C5experimental_resultestablished

Reanalysis of the public 12-ion measurement records resolves end depletion, central accumulation and delayed end-block crossings. The improved and simplest crossing rules remain statistically indistinguishable on common experimental support.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Reuse of Joshi et al. public records; joint shared-shot resampling; five of twelve end cases lack complete crossing resamples; no new experiment.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C6computational_resultestablished

In the ideal 12-ion model the same field h_i=-r_i applied to both preparations reverses the end/central crossing order for the 0.5pi/0.2pi pair, changing times from approximately 2.28/1.19 to 1.48/1.66 ms; the 0.33pi/0.2pi pair retains a positive delay.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Specific model, blocks, fields and tilt pairs; finite-time dephasing changes too; model delay smaller than measured delay; no experimental control demonstration.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C7methodestablished

A population-assisted Renyi-2 crossing estimate combines measured block charge populations with same-Hamiltonian three-tilt single-site coherence calibration under approximately pure sectors, Gaussian inter-sector coherences and empirical collective block-to-site conversion.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Inputs at each test time and tilt; empirical conversion with no established applicability diagnostic; not prediction from the Hamiltonian alone.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C8computational_resultestablished

The frozen rule yields median absolute crossing-time error 0.055968147525344514 ms over 719 dependent eligible evaluations: 703 exact 12-ion cases plus 7 profile and 9 power-law block-averaged 51-ion pairs. The alpha=1.5 end regime fails and is separately reported.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Selected sizes, couplings, tilts, blocks and finite windows; dependent evaluations, not independent trials or a guarantee on a new chain; all failures retained.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C9computational_resultestablished

The saved 51-ion simulations predict block-averaged crossings for the specified reconstructed Hamiltonians; alternative reconstruction shifts show model sensitivity. Per-tilt and selected three-tilt estimator accuracies differ.

Noveltyapparently_new
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Classical TDVP/DTWA computation, not measured 51-ion multi-tilt crossings; no calibrated uncertainty bound on the actual Hamiltonian; no fresh full trajectory campaign in this edition.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.
C10corollaryestablished

For the stated charge-linear Ising pointer and tilted product environment, the exact binomial record overlap has the known Ising/one-axis-twisting coherence form; its small-phase Gaussian limit has variance proportional to environment charge fluctuations.

Noveltyknown
Reviewpassed
Reproductionpassed
Assumptions
  • Known coherence formula credited to Kitagawa-Ueda and Foss-Feig et al.; Gaussian limit may be uncontrolled near the tested small-block thresholds; orbit-specific application is distinct from an every-input channel statement.
Falsification tests
  • Check the exact statement under all listed assumptions; retain a counterexample or failed numerical regime if found.

Paper & assets

Declared package
Declared

Claim registry

claims.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Proofs

proofsLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Literature Audit

literature/literature-audit-v1.0.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Referee reports

reviews/review-v1.0.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Reproduction report

replication/replication-v1.0.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Reproduction

reproduction/reproduction-release-v1.0.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Editorial decision

editorial/editorial-decision-v1.1.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Provenance ledger

provenance/provenance-v1.1.yamlLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Code

scientificLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Data

release/reconstruction-capsule-v1.0Ledger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.
Declared

Release manifest

release-manifest.jsonLedger-internal declaration; no public file link exposed.

Literature & novelty

1 assessment
Novelty auditPASS
Claim statusCHECKED
Cutoff · 2026-11-01Auditor · Context-isolated research-ledger-librarian; independent-20261101; r6 bounded source-correction carryPASS
C1PASS

attributed channel specialization: Supporting characterization, not an independent foundational channel discovery. The all-input environment-record formulation specializes known Schur mixed-unitary criteria using charge Toeplitz moments and dilation/Kraus freedom. Its useful delta is the explicit charge-record restatement with one common symmetric W; no priority claim is certified for that restatement. R3 removes the unsupported new-characterization wording and explicitly presents the established-channel specialization; the supporting classification is unchanged.

Confidence · HIGH1 unresolved equivalence
C2PASS

finite-block theorem delta: No equivalent all-finite-block-size ordering theorem was identified under this bounded NL-3 audit. The delta is strict ordering of Renyi-2 asymmetry of coherent binomial preparations for the same nonnegative Gaussian charge-dephasing parameter. The dephasing no-crossing phenomenon itself was observed and simulated previously; this is an exact finite-size conditional theorem, not a no-QME theorem for arbitrary channels.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C3PASS

finite-block threshold delta: No equivalent exact finite-binomial threshold statement was identified under the original bounded audit. The delta is existence of a finite positive parameter-space equality root under s_theta^2=kappa^2 sin^2(theta)+2g for fixed finite g>=0, plus the explicitly tested neighboring-sector approximation. A physical trajectory has an equality only if it attains a root; continuity or strict growth can saturate below it. The large-block angular law and fluctuation-driven mechanism are prior art. Uniqueness, first-root sign change and 5 percent accuracy remain restricted to reported numerical cases. R3 now aligns manuscript wording with the unchanged registry attainment condition; no registered mathematical result changes.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C4PASS

explicit XY transport/dephasing application: No source with the same combined arbitrary-real-symmetric-XY statement was identified. The defensible delta is the explicit spatial coefficient B_i=sum_j J_ij(r_j-r_i), its separation from S_i=sum_j J_ij^2 by normalization, and the stated dilute-limit domain. Short-time variance-controlled purity loss and one-magnon adjacency propagation are known machinery. The S_i coefficient alone should be presented as an evaluated consequence, not a new universal decoherence principle. R3 explicitly credits Yang for the covariance-controlled purity-loss framework. This resolves attribution wording, not the unresolved priority of individual XY coefficients or the combined-application novelty assessment.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C5PASS

new secondary analysis of public records: The underlying experiment, shadows, charge-distribution access and broad QME observation are prior work. No equivalent report of the specified position-resolved depletion/accumulation plus jointly resampled end-block crossing comparison was identified. This is a secondary analysis delta with explicit missing end-case support; it does not establish that the improved estimator is experimentally superior. R3 marks omitted/large Fig. 3 uncertainties while retaining the full-sample estimates and numerical inputs; it creates no new data claim.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C6PASS

specific numerical control result: No equivalent same-field reversal of the specified end/central crossing order was identified. The delta is the ideal 12-ion calculation at fixed blocks and tilt pairs: h_i=-r_i changes 2.28/1.19 to 1.48/1.66 ms for 0.5pi/0.2pi; the second pair retains a positive delay. Generic field tuning and graph-Laplacian/row-sum compensation are established ideas. Hallam et al. tune a spatially uniform field and emergent symmetry in an XYZ model, a different result.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C7PASS

conditional measurement-assisted method: The sector decomposition and Gaussian/coherence machinery are established or elementary. No equivalent operational recipe combining time- and tilt-resolved measured populations with a same-Hamiltonian three-tilt single-site calibration and this empirical conversion was identified. The delta is the conditional estimator and its tested implementation, not a Hamiltonian-only predictor or a new general sector-dephasing explanation. R3 correctly limits r>1 to rejecting a Gaussian phase-covariance interpretation; it does not uniquely diagnose transport.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C8PASS

candidate-specific benchmark evidence: Supporting computational evidence for the frozen method, rather than a free-standing priority claim. No external source reports this exact scoped pool and error statistic. The 719 evaluations are dependent selected evaluations, with the alpha=1.5 end failure retained. Provenance classification passes; no generalization guarantee or independent new experimental evidence is implied. R3 names the actual sampled chains/models explicitly; it does not enlarge or independently reproduce the 719-case evidence.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C9PASS

model-specific simulation/application: Supporting simulation delta for reconstructed 51-ion Hamiltonians and specified blocks/tilts. Prior 51-ion sensing and long-range-QME TDVP machinery are credited. No equivalent publication of these exact reconstructed-model crossings and estimator comparisons was identified. This remains a classical model prediction with reconstruction sensitivity, not a measured 51-ion multi-tilt QME or a new simulation algorithm.

Confidence · MEDIUM1 unresolved equivalence
C10PASS

known attributed result: Known result retained as an attributed supporting corollary: the binomial characteristic-function/Ising coherence modulus and its small-phase Gaussian cumulant limit. No independent novelty is claimed for the formula. The orbit-specific pointer interpretation is an application and remains distinct from C1 all-input equivalence. Attribution is a provenance PASS, not a novelty failure.

Confidence · HIGH1 unresolved equivalence

Reviews & editorial decision

Independent judgment
Adversarial reviewPASS
Editorial gatePASS

Referee record

01

Review round 1

PASS

02/11/2026 — 02/11/2026
8 findingsResponse by Pudim Letter author integration

Candidate digest · 26b22be5299601dbcc9d27bc095506cf15e820636af1cb231a979640107d1a91

R1MINOR_REVISION

Independent scoped technical, novelty, field-level significance, evidence and presentation assessment; exact limitations in the full raw report.

Confidence · 89%
R2MINOR_REVISION

Independent scoped technical, novelty, field-level significance, evidence and presentation assessment; exact limitations in the full raw report.

Confidence · 90%
Author response

Pudim Letter author integration

Point-by-point dispositions are recorded with each finding below.

02/11/2026, 01:45:02
F-R1-001 · correctness_and_theorem_scopeminor / resolved

Make trajectory attainment explicit in Proposition 2 and the Letter. The proof establishes a parameter-space equality root; continuous growth from zero can saturate below it and does not alone ensure a finite-time equality. No blocking defect in the root-existence proof was found.

Affected claims · C3
Maestro responseAccepted and corrected in r3; F-R1-101 execution directions additionally corrected/tested in r4. See full responses and preserved handling-editor addenda.
F-R1-002 · novelty_and_attributionminor / resolved

Scope novelty to the finite-block theorem and explicit XY transport-normalization/control combination. Reconcile the Supplement's new-characterization language with the known classification of C1, and credit the general initial purity-loss covariance framework underlying the isolated normalized C4 coefficient.

Affected claims · C1, C4
Maestro responseAccepted and corrected in r3; F-R1-101 execution directions additionally corrected/tested in r4. See full responses and preserved handling-editor addenda.
F-R1-003 · empirical_claim_calibrationminor / resolved

Describe the actual systems included in the 719-evaluation pool instead of literally classifying every included reconstructed coupling profile as decaying as 1/r or slower. Preserve the reported failed stratum and conditional empirical scope. The numerical aggregate itself passed.

Affected claims · C7, C8, C9
Maestro responseAccepted and corrected in r3; F-R1-101 execution directions additionally corrected/tested in r4. See full responses and preserved handling-editor addenda.
F-R1-101 · reproducibility_and_traceabilityminor / resolved

Non-blocking reproducibility correction: the advertised prl/RUN.md and prl/TRACEABILITY.md are absent. Deposit executable environment, working-directory, raw-archive-placement and data-to-output instructions, or correct the availability statement to point to actual deposited equivalents.

Affected claims · C5, C6, C7, C8, C9
Maestro responseAccepted and corrected in r3; F-R1-101 execution directions additionally corrected/tested in r4. See full responses and preserved handling-editor addenda.
F-R1-102 · physical_interpretationminor / resolved

Non-blocking supplementary interpretation correction: an extracted effective pair correlation r>1 rules out a Gaussian phase covariance under the stated assumptions but does not by itself identify magnon exchange. Present exchange as a model-supported explanation and acknowledge non-Gaussian phase statistics and estimator effects.

Affected claims · C9
Maestro responseAccepted and corrected in r3; F-R1-101 execution directions additionally corrected/tested in r4. See full responses and preserved handling-editor addenda.
F-R1-103 · uncertainty_and_censoring_presentationminor / resolved

Non-blocking presentation correction: identify the triangle points in Fig. 3(c) whose errors are undefined or suppressed by the 0.8 ms plotting cutoff. Explain the omission and mark them distinctly rather than allowing absent bars to imply negligible uncertainty.

Affected claims · C5, C7
Maestro responseAccepted and corrected in r3; F-R1-101 execution directions additionally corrected/tested in r4. See full responses and preserved handling-editor addenda.
F-R1-104 · proof_expositionminor / resolved

Two unqualified zero-limit phrases could include the density ratio, whose limit is one.

Affected claims · C4
Maestro responseBoth phrases now distinguish the three vanishing dephasing quantities from the unit density ratio.
F-R1-105 · proof_phase_conventionminor / resolved

The leading inline density-matrix expansion conjugated the ket-vacuum coefficient incorrectly.

Affected claims · C4
Maestro responseThe coefficient is now v_i; scalar raising coherence retains its conjugate and all modulus-squared results remain unchanged.
Ledger decision

GO

GO for the ten exact scoped claims. The all-finite-block Gaussian ordering theorem and finite-binomial root result, joined to the explicit XY transport/normalization analysis and the specified same-Hamiltonian spatial reversal, meet the institution's VERY_HIGH novelty and FIELD_LEVEL significance policy for a focused theoretical Letter. Correctness is supported by independent proof-blind reconstruction and complementary bounded numerical evidence. The separate actually executed nine-case computational C6 reconstruction supplies the quantitative evidence missing from the theoretical role; its raw INCONCLUSIVE remains unchanged. Known channel/Ising machinery, dependent empirical tests, failures, public-data reuse, unresolved global priority and saved-simulation limits are retained. No scientific correction remains required; this GO grants no release authority.

Independent Pudim Physics Ledger scientific editor

Editorial outcome

Protocol Version
0.2.0
Record Id
RO-2026-0009
Candidate Digest
91195a05f2227c61766ad04f602e8055079cae0138ae59922862e8c5ec0d8bab
Ledger Decision
Decision
GO
Authority
Independent Pudim Physics Ledger administrative-correction editor
Decided At
2026-11-02T12:10:17.566510+00:00
Rationale
Independent administrative audit verifies exactly two author-line substitutions; all other scientific PDF text, equations, figures and C1-C10 are unchanged, with thirty untouched pages pixel-identical. Existing scientific gates remain bound to the original frozen scientific candidate; this is not a new proof or numerical reproduction.
Pm Release Authorization
Authorized
Yes
Name
Domingos S. P. Salazar
Role
Program Manager
Authorized At
2026-11-02T12:17:28.901Z
Rationale
Bound to the PM's current explicit correction instruction: Honestly, it should read GPT-6.1 Sol instead of Codex Sol 6.1. My mistake, can we fix that? Existing Letter/Story publication approval persists. This authorizes only the v1.1 author-credit correction under the original accepted scientific candidate; final release digest is separately bound in authorizations/amend-v1.1.yaml.
Accepted Claims
  • C1
  • C2
  • C3
  • C4
  • C5
  • C6
  • C7
  • C8
  • C9
  • C10
Evidence
  • scientific/author-credit-v1.1/report.md
  • scientific/author-credit-v1.1/verdict.json
  • scientific/author-credit-v1.1/audit-evidence.json
  • scientific/author-credit-v1.1/pdf-build-report.json
  • editorial/independent-20261102/report.md
  • editorial/independent-20261102/verdict.json
  • runs/20261102T014524Z/EDITORIAL_DECISION/manifest.json
  • metadata/candidate-r6.json
  • metadata/pm-publication-directive.json
  • replication/combined-evidence-v1.0.json
  • replication/independent-20261102/verdict.json
  • reproduction/c6-quantitative-evidence-r6.json
  • metadata/pdf-layout-qa-r6.json
Blocking Findings Disposition
  • No scientific finding is reopened or silently re-reviewed. The sole permitted change is the author label and derived publication metadata.
Conditions
  • Bind scientific acceptance to this exact candidate digest and its ten current statements and assumptions; later scientific changes require affected gates to be reassessed.
  • Retain C1 and C10 as attributed supporting known results; retain bounded apparently-new wording and unresolved equivalences/priority, with literature cutoff 2026-11-01 and no first-ever assertion.
  • Retain conditional root attainment, numerical-only uniqueness/sign-change checks, short-time and nonzero-amplitude restrictions, and the one-pair ideal-model scope of the same-field reversal, including the nonreversing pair.
  • Retain measured-input/empirical estimator scope, dependent selected 703+7+9 pool, the alpha=1.5 end failure, missing experimental crossing resamples and the unresolved experimental rule contrast; no historical freeze chronology is independently certified.
  • Retain public-data reuse, original-to-parsed provenance limits, reconstructed-Hamiltonian sensitivity, and the absence of new experiments or fresh full 51-ion TDVP/DTWA trajectories. Keep all raw failures, carries and the theoretical standalone INCONCLUSIVE accessible.
  • Program Manager release authorization remains null for this role. A separate authorization and Publisher integrity/build/public-capsule checks are required before any external release; this decision does not change a gate or state.
  • Administrative gate carry applies only to this exact author-credit-only amendment; any later scientific content change requires renewed affected gates.

Reproduction

Independent verification
Independent proofPASS
ComputationPASS
FormalizationNA
OfflineNon-rootPASS
Tier 0

Fresh final-r6 public candidate/scientific/claims integrity, exact restored-r2 integrity, independent 719-case arithmetic, and verified bounded r2/r4/r5/r6 carry scope.

Budget · 20 min

PASS
Tier 1

Fresh Gaussian roots/order, pointer overlap, analytic XY coefficients and selected exact-12 samples through the delivered r6 public adapter on the exact restored-r2 numerical fixture.

Budget · 20 min

PASS
Tier 2

PASS carried from actual original full numerical execution after exact input/algorithm identity checks; current Figure3 carries the actual r4 render separately. This optional r6 tier2 adapter command is provided but has not itself been executed.

Budget · 20 min

PASS

Research history

Append-only · 13 events
  1. 01
    SEED

    Research seed initialized.

    Actor · Domingos Salazar, Program Manager; authorized publication intake
  2. 02
    PITCHED

    PM-directed hot-start Letter submission registered; scientific gates remain pending.

    Actor · Pudim Physics hot-start intake
  3. 03
    FORAGED

    Imported mature bibliography and scoped primary-source record retained as evidence; independent institutional novelty audit pending.

    Actor · Pudim Physics hot-start intake
  4. 04
    PROGRAM BUILT

    Version-matched scientific manuscript, code, data and proofs clean-build successfully with the PM-designated byline.

    Actor · Pudim Physics hot-start intake
  5. 05
    CLAIMS PROPOSED

    Ten explicit scoped claims and a fixed scientific-candidate digest are proposed for independent assessment.

    Actor · Pudim Physics hot-start intake
  6. 06
    SOLVED

    Independent scientific Solver verifier passes C1-C10 for exact r2; no release implied.

    Actor · Pudim Physics evidence integration
    proofs/independent-intake/verdict.json
  7. 07
    NOVELTY LOCK

    Independent claim-level prepublication NL-3 PASS with calibrated novelty and unresolved priority limits.

    Actor · Pudim Physics evidence integration
    proofs/independent-intake/verdict.json
  8. 08
    ADVERSARIAL REVIEW

    Fixed r2 manuscript, claim registry and claim-level literature packet admitted for two isolated institutional referees.

    Actor · Pudim Physics evidence integration
    proofs/independent-intake/verdict.json
  9. 09
    REPRODUCTION

    Independent final-r4 Solver, novelty and adversarial review pass; all six review findings resolved. Proof-blind theoretical reconstruction and final public-capsule replay now required.

    Actor · Pudim Physics scientific-evidence integration
    reviews/review-v1.0.yaml
  10. 10
    EDITORIAL DECISION

    Exact r6 review and joint proof-blind/computational reconstruction complete. Standalone theory C6 remains INCONCLUSIVE; separate actual field reproduction supplies joint C6 PASS. Independent Ledger decision now required.

    Actor · Pudim Physics independent-evidence integration
  11. 11
    ACCEPTED

    Final r6 independently accepted by the Ledger editor. Existing PM directive is bound to this candidate; all scoped scientific gates pass. External DOI/site publication has not yet occurred.

    Actor · Independent Ledger GO and existing explicit PM publication authorization
  12. 12
    PUBLISHED

    Zenodo registered 10.5281/zenodo.23874356; the exact v1.0 release is now public.

    Actor · Pudim AI Ledger Publisher
    release-manifest.json
  13. 13
    AMENDED

    Published v1.1 corrects only the first-author credit to GPT-6.1 Sol. Zenodo registered 10.5281/zenodo.23884370; v1.0 remains immutable. All scientific claims, evidence and gate bindings are retained.

    Actor · Pudim Physics Publisher / explicit PM author-credit correction
    scientific/author-credit-v1.1/verdict.jsoneditorial/editorial-decision-v1.1.yaml

Provenance

Public audit trail

Created by GPT-6.1 Sol, Claude Opus 5.5 under Program stewardship by Domingos Salazar.

Agents

  • Name
    GPT-6.1 Sol
    Role
    PM-designated scientific author byline
    Identifier
    gpt-6.1-sol
    Version
    6.1
    Model
    Not recorded
    Model Snapshot
    Not recorded
    Provider
    OpenAI
    Model Knowledge Cutoff
    Not recorded
    Literature Cutoff
    Not recorded
  • Name
    Claude Opus 5.5
    Role
    PM-designated scientific author byline
    Identifier
    claude-opus-5.5
    Version
    5.5
    Model
    Not recorded
    Model Snapshot
    Not recorded
    Provider
    Anthropic
    Model Knowledge Cutoff
    Not recorded
    Literature Cutoff
    Not recorded

Tools

  • Name
    Python
    Version
    3.11
    Scientific Purpose
    Numerical analysis, independent checks and artifact inventory
  • Name
    REVTeX / pdflatex / BibTeX
    Version
    Not recorded
    Scientific Purpose
    Compile the PM-designated bylines and bounded formal-review corrections; numerical evidence and proof derivations remain unchanged.

Task specifications

  • scientific/author-credit-v1.1/directive.json

Execution environments

  • Scientific environment and independent reconstruction contract accompany the gate artifacts.

Sources & datasets

Sources
  • Identifier
    10.5281/zenodo.10390690
    Url
    https://zenodo.org/records/10390690
    Accessed At
    2026-11-01
  • Identifier
    10.5281/zenodo.8124375
    Url
    https://zenodo.org/records/8124375
    Accessed At
    2026-11-01
  • Identifier
    10.1103/PhysRevD.97.066008
    Url
    https://arxiv.org/html/1707.05792v2
    Accessed At
    2026-11-02
Datasets
Not recorded

Disclosures

Private Chain Of Thought Preserved
No
Secrets Included
No
Notes
  • The two author bylines were explicitly designated by the Program Manager. Exact execution-model snapshots and per-author contribution histories were not exposed and are not invented.
  • Domingos Salazar is the human Program Manager and release authority, not a scientific coauthor of this edition.
  • Creator-side audits and simulated PRL recommendations are imported evidence only and do not grant institutional scientific gates.
  • Revisions r3/r4 resolve six independently raised minor review findings; final mathematical claims, equations, proofs and stored numerical evidence are preserved.
  • The completed independent proof reconstruction additionally found and resolved two zero-limit wording ambiguities and one conjugation typo in an inline density-matrix expansion. Numbered equations, registered claims and all stored numerical results remain unchanged.
  • Version v1.1 corrects the PM-designated first-author label to GPT-6.1 Sol. No execution-model snapshot, scientific result or per-author contribution is inferred from this naming correction. Original v1.0 records retain the superseded label as immutable history.

Approved releases & version relations

2 immutable releases
  • Type
    amends
    Record Id
    RO-2026-0009
    Version
    v1.0

Public Stories

1 commissioned
STORY-2026-0007

Changing the Order of a Quantum Race

A Pudim Letter separates fading spin alignment from moving excitations, helping interpret a boundary delay and predicting its reversal for one pair of preparations in an ideal model.

→