Public ledger / Deterministic search
Find the claim. Follow its evidence.
Search Programs, Research Objects, claims, literature comparisons, and review findings. Protected accepted previews are labeled and remain outside the public API.
RO-2026-0001 C1
For any occupied spectral partition of an SLD-regular one-parameter quantum model, the Fisher-information loss equals the state-weighted within-bin SLD score variance and is at most one quarter of the state-weighted squared bin diameters; consequently any occupied bins of diameter at most delta lose at most delta squared divided by four.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0001:C2RO-2026-0001 C2
The optimal few-outcome SLD readout admits a dimension-free central-plus-tail bound, is stable under Wasserstein-2 perturbations of the state-weighted score measure, has a dense-spectrum high-rate quantization window, and crosses exactly to zero distortion once the bin count reaches the finite score-support size.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0001:C3RO-2026-0001 C3
For a rank-one projective measurement, the quantum-Fisher loss equals the rho-weighted squared residual between its induced score operator and the SLD, providing an exact projective-search stopping certificate; the broader local-to-global and pair-rotation geometry is an imported companion result.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0001:C4RO-2026-0001 C4
For an actual parameter-independent initialized isometry V with exhaustive ordinary, boundary, leakage, and failure labels, a bounded label-score observable C, and an approximate Hermitian SLD L-tilde, the uniform score-intertwining defect xi = norm(CV - V L-tilde) controls the actual POVM Fisher loss by (eta + xi)^2. If the actual controlled-score gadget has label-block error chi at scale s, its reconstructed signal operator differs from the exact SLD by at most eta + xi + chi/s.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0001:C5RO-2026-0001 C5
Producing a coherent SLD score instrument that satisfies the declared score-intertwining and signal-block interface at inverse-polynomial accuracy is BQP-hard for a faithful, trace-normalized, full-support metrological embedding with polynomial state conditioning, inverse-polynomial zero-score margin, inverse-polynomial quantum Fisher information, and inverse-polynomial coherent application success, even though the sensor-state score histogram is independent of the encoded linear-system right-hand side.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0001:C6RO-2026-0001 C6
The parity-coherence sensing family has constant condition number three, quantum Fisher information n divided by four, exactly n plus one SLD scores, and logarithmic score-register size, while Gibbs access obeys the rescaling-invariant conditioning obstruction exp(beta times energy span) and the archived finite-size beta proportional to one over n family has bounded conditioning together with the reported rescaled sensitivity.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0001:C7RO-2026-0001 C7
In the archived frustrated four-spin sensor benchmark, the best product projective readout found by the archived heuristic search retains 48.55 percent of the quantum Fisher information, whereas globally optimized contiguous seven- and eight-bin SLD score readouts retain 98.34 percent and 99.26 percent respectively.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C1RO-2026-0003 C1
For faithful finite-dimensional states and every fixed integer n >= 2, measured relative entropy on n tensor copies equals n times its one-copy value if and only if the states commute.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C2RO-2026-0003 C2
For every faithful noncommuting state pair, a phase-optimized rotation of two product measurement vectors has a strictly positive directional derivative of the two-copy measured relative entropy at the product optimum.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C3RO-2026-0003 C3
The fixed-horizon specialization of the known Li-Tan-Tomamichel adaptive bound implies that any fresh-copy measurement protocol with classical feed-forward has classical relative entropy at most n times the one-copy measured relative entropy.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C4RO-2026-0003 C4
For a Gibbs-prepared isolated unitary drive, the dimensionless irreversible work beta times W minus Delta F equals D(rho_tau || pi_tau).
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C5RO-2026-0003 C5
In the faithful finite-temperature IID isolated-drive construction, strict globally optimized two-copy gain in measured relative entropy is equivalent to nonzero energetic coherence relative to the final Hamiltonian.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C6RO-2026-0003 C6
A calibrated positive implemented two-copy gain is a one-sided witness within the stated model, whereas a null restricted gain does not establish incoherence.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C7RO-2026-0003 C7
The stated faithful qubit family has a certified x-basis one-copy optimum and an explicit positive-slope two-copy rotation.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0003:C8RO-2026-0003 C8
On the deterministic 453-point qubit grid, the maximum recovered globally optimized gain is 0.0214758723 nats per copy and the explicit rotation attains 0.0073100901 nats per copy at the best displayed point.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C1RO-2026-0004 C1
The known equality between cooling-map and low-temperature thermal-operation state-transition power for a two-level system fails at the first open dimension under the exact finite-bath, ground-state-subspace convention: every irrational parameter in the displayed qutrit family gives a cooling-map transition that is not exactly reachable by that thermal class.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C10RO-2026-0004 C10
At cold-limit errors 10^-4, 10^-8, and 10^-12, the theorem lower bounds are 13, 1280, and 128000, while the displayed golden Fibonacci construction dimensions are 288, 21892, and 2692538.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C11RO-2026-0004 C11
The exact two-subspace construction has the stated gap-calibration tolerance, while the equal-rank approximation construction is independent of temperature.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C2RO-2026-0004 C2
For distinct nonzero qutrit Bohr frequencies, every qutrit cooling map lies in the diamond-norm closure of exact finite-bath thermal operations initialized on their ground-state subspaces.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C3RO-2026-0004 C3
Every D-dimensional finite Gibbs-bath implementation of the displayed qutrit channel obeys kappa_D(a)/D^2 <= exp(-beta Delta)/4 + (12+8 sqrt(2)) epsilon.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C4RO-2026-0004 C4
For each fixed badly approximable target and sufficiently small combined thermal-and-error scale, the minimum bath dimension lies between explicit positive target-dependent constants times the inverse square root of that scale.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C5RO-2026-0004 C5
For every positive nu and Lebesgue-almost every target, the minimum dimension has an inverse-square-root lower law with the stated logarithmic loss for sufficiently small combined thermal-and-error scale.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C6RO-2026-0004 C6
A rational target a=p/q has an exact two-energy-subspace implementation with total dimension 2q; explicit Fibonacci choices give approximation constructions for the golden-conjugate target, while a=1/2 has dimension four.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C7RO-2026-0004 C7
Shellwise polar rounding and projection rigidity give a parameter-uniform linear bound on the difference between the bath projection expectation and the target mixing parameter despite population leakage.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C8RO-2026-0004 C8
On a joint finite-confidence event, the actual bath dimension and ground-state degeneracy obey the sharpened dimension-exclusion inequality in the Letter; a candidate dimension is excluded only when every allowed degeneracy fails it.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0004:C9RO-2026-0004 C9
The rigid phase pair belongs to a one-parameter family, and the coefficient delivered by the proof is minimized when the absolute phase parameter equals one, where it is 12+8 sqrt(2).
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C1RO-2026-0005 C1
Established driven-energy-diffusion ingredients and thermal Kramers diffusion form a density-of-states-consistent stochastic thermodynamics when deterministic protocol transport is fixed by phase-volume continuity and entropy is defined relative to the density of states.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C2RO-2026-0005 C2
Positive homogeneous Hamiltonians close on a gamma energy family controlled by effective degrees of freedom, while their relaxation and power scale with the homogeneity-dependent energy relaxation rate.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C3RO-2026-0005 C3
For the established gamma-difference thermal-exchange family, one contrast variable yields a compact all-order cumulant recurrence, incomplete-beta wrong-way probability, exact finite-time gamma-family exchange uncertainty identity, skewness, and kurtosis; the distinct total path entropy production also has a closed distribution. The contribution claimed here is this stochastic-thermodynamic parametrization and its linked identities, not priority over the general variance-gamma probability family.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C4RO-2026-0005 C4
A six-member finite-time cycle atlas separates imposed topology from continuous control. Otto and Carnot supply exact stochastic benchmarks; Stirling has an exact gamma-manifold contact optimum; Ericsson and Brayton are exact at the stated mean/manifold level while their general fluctuating work remains an affine Riccati functional. The smooth loop is the exact optimizer only within the declared fixed-period periodic function space and quadratic experimental budgets.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C5RO-2026-0005 C5
For the nonlinear graph-metric power cage, equilibrium graph dependence is determined exactly by the Laplacian pseudodeterminant, effective resistances, and Kirchhoff index for arbitrary positive homogeneity degree.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C6RO-2026-0005 C6
For arbitrary positive homogeneity degree, a sudden single-edge quench of the nonlinear graph cage has an exact independent beta-gamma work representation controlled by the pre-quench effective resistance and yields all work moments and fluctuation relations. Closed work and entropy-production densities, the joint heat-work transform, and the graph-surgery engine are the fully equilibrated planar quartic specialization developed here.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C7RO-2026-0005 C7
Global stiffness and proportional graph breathing retain exact scalar energy closure, whereas generic finite-rate graph-shape driving requires shell mixing or additional angular observables.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0005:C8RO-2026-0005 C8
Within the explicitly conditional reduced model of rapid shell mixing and orbit-averaged moving-wall work, the hard-sphere configurational integral acts as a mechanical control; a uniform attractive mean field yields a nonequilibrium van der Waals correction, whereas microscopic attractive tails generally leave the scalar closure class. No trajectory-level convergence of microscopic hard-sphere dynamics to this reduced process is claimed.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C1RO-2026-0007 C1
For faithful finite-dimensional product hypotheses, the fully-PPT measured Pearson optimum equals the product of the one-copy optima and is attained by measuring an optimal score on each physical copy.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C2RO-2026-0007 C2
A faithful noncommuting state pair has a strict unrestricted joint two-copy Pearson gain over the fully-PPT product value.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C3RO-2026-0007 C3
For the prescribed collective score built from a faithful noncommuting pair, spectral readout adds no variance, whereas every unbiased fully-PPT readout of that same observable adds positive variance.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C4RO-2026-0007 C4
A moment inequality gives a necessary fully-PPT variance lower bound for the fixed collective score that can be stronger than the class-wide Pearson bound; it is not claimed to equal the unknown restricted minimum.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C5RO-2026-0007 C5
In the stated driven-medium model, energy dephasing removes the joint-readout Pearson gain while leaving the full two-point work distribution unchanged.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C6RO-2026-0007 C6
Reduced equilibrium probes in the specified separable probe-ancilla model exhibit the fixed-score readout penalty without a drive or entangled source.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0007:C7RO-2026-0007 C7
With characterized input states and calibrated outcome probabilities, a Pearson value above the product limit certifies an NPT readout effect in the stated copy partition.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C1RO-2026-0008 C1
For H=a*n_h+c*n_c and rho=tau_x tensor tau_y, with a,c,x,y>0, let e_-=min(a,c), e_+=max(a,c), q=min(x,y), D=|x-y|, C=(1-exp(-x))(1-exp(-y)), and K=floor(min(e_-/(e_+-e_-),q/D)), treating a zero denominator as infinity. Then 0<=W-W_G<=C*e_+*sum_{N=K+1}^infinity N(N+1)exp(-q*N), including energy/population ties. If both denominators vanish, the state is Gibbs and W=W_G=0.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C2RO-2026-0008 C2
For beta_h=beta*(1-epsilon), beta_c=beta*(1+epsilon), a/c=1+2*delta*epsilon/(1-epsilon), fixed b=beta*c>0, c>0 and real delta, as epsilon tends to zero through physical positive frequencies, 0<=W-W_G=O_{b,c,delta}(epsilon^(-2)*exp(-b/(2*max(delta,1-delta)*epsilon))).
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C3RO-2026-0008 C3
For the same family, with B the initial energy excess above the Gibbs state of equal entropy, lim_{epsilon->0} W/B equals 4*delta*(1-delta) for 0<delta<1 and zero for delta<=0 or delta>=1.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C4RO-2026-0008 C4
At fixed delta outside the open interval (0,1), the same family satisfies lim_{epsilon->0} epsilon*log(W/c)=-b/(2*max(delta,1-delta)); this logarithmic rate includes both endpoints and asserts no prefactor asymptotic.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C5RO-2026-0008 C5
For controls acting only on m+n<=M and as identity outside, the least resonance cutoff permitting positive work is floor((1-epsilon)/(2*epsilon))+2; inside 0<delta<1 the least cutoff is one. At fixed M and interior fixed delta, lim W_M/W=(1-z)^4*sum_{N=1}^M binomial(N+2,3)*z^(N-1), z=exp(-b), so any fixed fraction below one uses a bias-independent cutoff.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C6RO-2026-0008 C6
For full-rank finite-energy two-mode Gaussian states, Gaussian passification to a thermal product sigma_G yields W(rho)-W_G(rho)=W(sigma_G); C1 then bounds this non-Gaussian advantage because W_G(sigma_G)=0.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0008:C7RO-2026-0008 C7
The supplied 84-case passive-ordering sweep and repeated high-precision arithmetic comparisons check the declared finite models and asymptotic regimes; analytic omitted-energy bounds, not agreement of floating-point runs alone, control spectral truncation.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C1RO-2026-0009 C1
For a fixed purified environment input, the reduced block channel is a mixture of U(1) rotations followed by a charge-preserving unitary for every initial block state if and only if the stated charge-conditioned environment records exist with Toeplitz overlaps.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C10RO-2026-0009 C10
For the stated charge-linear Ising pointer and tilted product environment, the exact binomial record overlap has the known Ising/one-axis-twisting coherence form; its small-phase Gaussian limit has variance proportional to environment charge fluctuations.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C2RO-2026-0009 C2
For coherent tilted product preparations of every finite block size, tilt-independent nonnegative Gaussian charge dephasing with frozen binomial sector populations preserves the ordering of Renyi-2 entanglement asymmetry and produces no crossing.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C3RO-2026-0009 C3
Under the specified Gaussian frozen-population law at fixed finite nonnegative tilt-independent contribution, the asymmetry difference has a finite positive equality root as a function of the tilt-dependent dephasing parameter. A dynamical trajectory has an equality only if it reaches such a root. The neighboring-sector expression approximates the roots within 5 percent in the stated cases.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C4RO-2026-0009 C4
For a real symmetric XY coupling matrix and a globally tilted product state, the site density changes by -t^2 B_i sin^2(theta) cos(theta)/4 and normalized coherence dephasing by t^2 S_i sin^2(theta), with order-t^4 remainders; the dilute all-time normalized limit excludes zeros of the one-magnon amplitude.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C5RO-2026-0009 C5
Reanalysis of the public 12-ion measurement records resolves end depletion, central accumulation and delayed end-block crossings. The improved and simplest crossing rules remain statistically indistinguishable on common experimental support.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C6RO-2026-0009 C6
In the ideal 12-ion model the same field h_i=-r_i applied to both preparations reverses the end/central crossing order for the 0.5pi/0.2pi pair, changing times from approximately 2.28/1.19 to 1.48/1.66 ms; the 0.33pi/0.2pi pair retains a positive delay.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C7RO-2026-0009 C7
A population-assisted Renyi-2 crossing estimate combines measured block charge populations with same-Hamiltonian three-tilt single-site coherence calibration under approximately pure sectors, Gaussian inter-sector coherences and empirical collective block-to-site conversion.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C8RO-2026-0009 C8
The frozen rule yields median absolute crossing-time error 0.055968147525344514 ms over 719 dependent eligible evaluations: 703 exact 12-ion cases plus 7 profile and 9 power-law block-averaged 51-ion pairs. The alpha=1.5 end regime fails and is separately reported.
Open →claim · RO-2026-0009:C9RO-2026-0009 C9
The saved 51-ion simulations predict block-averaged crossings for the specified reconstructed Hamiltonians; alternative reconstruction shifts show model sensitivity. Per-tilt and selected three-tilt estimator accuracies differ.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C1
The candidate gives a support-aware specialization to regular SLD-score measures, a uniform spectral-diameter corollary, and integration with the later compiler and hardness interface; it does not claim priority for the conditional-variance identity or the one-quarter variance constant.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C2
The defensible contribution is the exact mapping from SLD-score loss to scalar distortion, the explicit tail construction, the changing-resolution Wasserstein transfer, and its combination with the exact finite-support crossover. Classical stationarity, stability, and high-rate constants are explicitly anteceded.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C3
The candidate imports and applies the companion projective-landscape theorem as an exact residual certificate; it does not re-claim that theorem as a new self-contained result.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C4
Sheng anteceded the generic Stinespring score-intertwining loss identity. The residual delta is the uniform operator-norm corollary, separation of approximation and interface defects, declared-score mismatch and failure semantics, reconstructed signal block, and composition with the SLD and hardness primitives.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C5
The candidate narrows the hardness result to coherent selected-input synthesis under full-support metrological promises and explicitly separates that interface from ordinary sampling, histogram estimation, and stronger classical access models.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C6
Cable, Gu, and Modi anteceded the parity-coherence state family and extensive sensitivity scaling. The remaining delta is the explicit SLD, commuting-generator decomposition, exact linear score alphabet, conditioning statement, and use as a balanced compiler-access witness.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0001:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0001:C7
This is a deterministic four-spin numerical readout benchmark and resource diagnostic, not an experiment or a claim of a globally optimized product measurement.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C1
Prior work gives the one-copy strict gap, asymptotic recovery, some finite strict tensor power, and broader set-valued superadditivity. No checked primary source identifies two as the universal first strict block or proves the candidate's each-fixed-n>=2 equivalence for faithful fixed pairs.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C2
The phase-adjusted rotation and projective calculus are inherited and explicitly credited. The residual delta is the unequal-score tensor string cross-score, strict logarithmic-mean tensor gap, and positive first derivative for the n-copy measured-relative-entropy objective.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C3
Known deterministic-horizon specialization with no novelty credit. The candidate's known-bound label and pinpoint citation are accurate.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C4
Known process-scoped identity with no novelty credit. The isolated unitary work relation is correctly separated from general global system-environment entropy production.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C5
The coherence decomposition and collective coherence measurements are prior. Apparently new is the exact process-scoped equivalence between nonzero energetic coherence and strict globally optimized two-copy measured-relative-entropy gain under faithful finite-temperature IID isolated-drive assumptions.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C6
Elementary consequence of the global optimization; useful operational wording rather than a major independent novelty claim. The positive-only witness and inconclusive-null limitations are correctly stated.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C7
Apparently new explicit qubit benchmark family instantiating the new tensor slope, built with prior variational certification machinery. Its conceptual novelty is subordinate to C1 and C2.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0003:literature:C8Literature audit for RO-2026-0003:C8
Candidate-specific deterministic 453-point numerical output. Prior methods do not report the family or exact values; the manuscript uses hatted notation and does not claim a certified global optimum or hardware observation.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C1
The 2015 work proves the two-level equality and poses the higher-dimensional direction; the present result gives an exact qutrit separation under a specified finite-bath ground-state-subspace convention.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C10Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C10
The displayed integers are deterministic consequences of C3 and C6 and receive no independent novelty credit.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C11Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C11
The local gap-calibration estimate and temperature-independent equal-rank branch are scoped stability properties of the explicit construction.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C2
The closure statement combines qutrit correlation-matrix decomposition with shellwise thermal implementation; no direct prior closure theorem was found.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C3
Prior finite-reservoir bounds control heat, work, accuracy, or other resources; no bound coupling coherent-channel diamond error to finite bath Hilbert-space dimension through Diophantine resistance was found.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C4
The two-sided inverse-square-root bath-dimension law for badly approximable channel weights was not found in the inspected finite-reservoir literature.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C5
The almost-everywhere lower law is a new application of classical metric Diophantine approximation to the channel-implementation bound.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C6
The explicit Gibbs-flag synthesis is a construction for the displayed family; controlled mixtures are standard, but this finite-bath arithmetic realization was not found.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C7
Polar rounding and finite tracial projection ideas are known ingredients; the leakage-robust linear estimate is claimed only in the paper's stated moment geometry.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C8Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C8
The ideal-model dimension-exclusion inference is an application of C3, not model-independent bath tomography.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0004:literature:C9Literature audit for RO-2026-0004:C9
The open one-parameter rigidity curve and coefficient minimization belong to the proof developed here; broader rigidity outside that curve remains open.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C1
The bath operator and driven-energy-diffusion ingredients are established. The release claims a thermodynamically consistent synthesis under energy lumpability, not the first driven energy-diffusion equation.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C2
Harmonic and one-dimensional power-law gamma/CIR closures and fractional effective degrees of freedom are known. The arbitrary-dimensional homogeneous organization and separation of thermodynamic size alpha from kinetic clock Gamma_q are retained as a unifying corollary, not a priority claim.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C3
The gamma-difference heat and exchange-entropy laws, generating function, and general moment structure are known. The accepted contribution is their single-contrast stochastic-thermodynamic parametrization, the linked uncertainty and sign identities, and the comparison with the distinct total-path entropy-production distribution; no priority over variance-gamma probability theory is claimed.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C4
Minimum-work trap protocols and named Brownian-engine cycles are established. The accepted delta is the exact smooth-loop optimizer within the explicitly bounded gamma-manifold admissible class and selected finite-time cycle identities.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C5
Pseudodeterminant, matrix-tree, effective-resistance, and spherical-projection ingredients are known; the release uses them as a solvable thermodynamic baseline without claiming a new graph theorem.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C6
No direct primary match was found for the arbitrary-q single-edge law beta W equals V times a nonlinear beta fraction, with graph dependence compressed to h=delta g R_e, nor for the resulting graph-surgery engine.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C7
Scalar closure under global scaling follows established adiabatic-invariant reasoning. The release's contribution is to state the closure boundary explicitly: generic graph-shape driving may require angular observables or extra mixing.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0005:literature:C8Literature audit for RO-2026-0005:C8
Fixed-volume kinetic CIR and phase-volume/compressibility ingredients are known. The moving-wall Q_G coordinate is admitted only as a conditional shell-averaged extension; no microscopic convergence or new van der Waals theory is claimed.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C1
No equivalent result was identified under NL-3 as of 2026-09-29. Registered C1 has exact Q_N^fullyPPT = Q_1^N for faithful finite-dimensional IID pairs with physical-copy PPT cuts and local-score attainment. The Letter proves a broader unequal-copy product extension, also compared here, but it is not separately registered in claims.yaml.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C2
No explicit universal strict two-copy measured-Pearson criterion or positive ordered-commutator surplus formula was identified under NL-3 as of 2026-09-29. Credit is objective-specific; the general two-copy collective-gain phenomenon and relative-entropy analogue are prior.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C3
No equivalent state-calibrated fixed-score fully-PPT positive added-variance statement was identified under NL-3 as of 2026-09-29. This theoretical witness depends on C1-C2 plus known POVM variance decomposition; it is not an implemented receiver, an exact PPT minimum, or independent novelty in quantum measurement noise.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C4
A scoped detector-effect moment refinement for prescribed-operator readout was not found explicitly under NL-3 as of 2026-09-29. It is only a necessary lower bound and carries limited independent conceptual novelty.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C5
The four-spin model calculation and its scoped comparison of disappearing Pearson readout surplus with unchanged full two-point work histogram appear candidate-specific. No credit is assigned to the general dephasing or work-statistics mechanism.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C6
The fixed-score fully-PPT variance hierarchy evaluated on the imported reduced-equilibrium model appears candidate-specific. Neither the Hamiltonian nor coherence-enhanced local thermometry is new here.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0007:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0007:C7
The calibrated population bound Q_n > Q_1^n excludes every fully-PPT POVM and implies at least one NPT effect by C1. Full outcome probabilities and a characterized input pair are required. This is a dependent theoretical corollary, not independent priority for entangled-measurement certification or a finite-shot detector demonstration.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C1
PASS for the explicit finite, tie-inclusive bound Ce_+ sum_{N>K} N(N+1)e^{-qN}, with K=floor(min(e_-/(e_+-e_-),q/|x-y|)), on the full-unitary advantage over the Gaussian optimum for a specified thermal product. The Gaussian optimum and passive rearrangement are established ingredients. The candidate adds the simultaneous energy/population shell-prefix criterion and a computable residual tail estimate; no equivalent result was identified under the recorded NL-3-bounded search.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C2
PASS as a corollary of C1 for a specific joint limit: fixed b,c,delta and epsilon down to zero, with detuning proportional to bias. The delta-dependent absolute remainder O(epsilon^{-2} exp(-b/[2 max(delta,1-delta) epsilon])) is the defensible addition. It is not an original Gaussian protocol, a fixed-frequency-mismatch theorem, or an exact interior rate.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C3
PASS only for the limiting fraction of the full arbitrary-unitary ergotropy relative to the equal-entropy Gibbs bound, obtained through C1/C2. The swap work, its window, the Gibbs bound, and the leading Gaussian parabola are established or elementary consequences. The claim upgrades the Gaussian ratio to W/B and fixes its exterior value to zero; novelty does not lie in naming a parabola or in the denominator itself.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C4
PASS for the matching logarithmic rate of the unrestricted optimum outside the open swap window, including both endpoints. High-occupation activation and nonlinear extraction beyond the swap window are not new. The delta-dependent sharp exponential scale, backed by upper and lower constructions and with no prefactor claim, is the defensible delta.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C5
PASS as a supporting quantitative refinement: the exact least resonance occupation cutoff, plus the fixed-M captured-work fraction (1-z)^4 sum_{N=1}^M binomial(N+2,3) z^{N-1}. Inverse-bias high-occupation activation is established. The finite sum is a standard negative-binomial cumulative expression; novelty is its identification with this restricted-work fraction and comparison with the full optimum, not a new combinatorial identity.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C6
PASS only as an application of C1 to full-rank finite-energy Gaussian inputs. The Gaussian normal form and the identity W(rho)-W_G(rho)=W(sigma_G) are established/elementary; the residual-energy identity is explicitly equivalent to Quintela Rodriguez et al. Eq. (78) on a Gaussian unitary orbit. The new content is substitution into C1. An independent-priority claim for this identity would FAIL.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0008:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0008:C7
PASS for novelty framing only: the stated 84-case finite-model sweep is supporting numerical validation, not a claim of a new historical theorem or experiment. This audit did not rerun code, inspect numerical outputs, verify precision, or grant the computational/reproduction gate.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C1Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C1
attributed channel specialization: Supporting characterization, not an independent foundational channel discovery. The all-input environment-record formulation specializes known Schur mixed-unitary criteria using charge Toeplitz moments and dilation/Kraus freedom. Its useful delta is the explicit charge-record restatement with one common symmetric W; no priority claim is certified for that restatement. R3 removes the unsupported new-characterization wording and explicitly presents the established-channel specialization; the supporting classification is unchanged.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C10Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C10
known attributed result: Known result retained as an attributed supporting corollary: the binomial characteristic-function/Ising coherence modulus and its small-phase Gaussian cumulant limit. No independent novelty is claimed for the formula. The orbit-specific pointer interpretation is an application and remains distinct from C1 all-input equivalence. Attribution is a provenance PASS, not a novelty failure.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C2Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C2
finite-block theorem delta: No equivalent all-finite-block-size ordering theorem was identified under this bounded NL-3 audit. The delta is strict ordering of Renyi-2 asymmetry of coherent binomial preparations for the same nonnegative Gaussian charge-dephasing parameter. The dephasing no-crossing phenomenon itself was observed and simulated previously; this is an exact finite-size conditional theorem, not a no-QME theorem for arbitrary channels.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C3Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C3
finite-block threshold delta: No equivalent exact finite-binomial threshold statement was identified under the original bounded audit. The delta is existence of a finite positive parameter-space equality root under s_theta^2=kappa^2 sin^2(theta)+2g for fixed finite g>=0, plus the explicitly tested neighboring-sector approximation. A physical trajectory has an equality only if it attains a root; continuity or strict growth can saturate below it. The large-block angular law and fluctuation-driven mechanism are prior art. Uniqueness, first-root sign change and 5 percent accuracy remain restricted to reported numerical cases. R3 now aligns manuscript wording with the unchanged registry attainment condition; no registered mathematical result changes.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C4Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C4
explicit XY transport/dephasing application: No source with the same combined arbitrary-real-symmetric-XY statement was identified. The defensible delta is the explicit spatial coefficient B_i=sum_j J_ij(r_j-r_i), its separation from S_i=sum_j J_ij^2 by normalization, and the stated dilute-limit domain. Short-time variance-controlled purity loss and one-magnon adjacency propagation are known machinery. The S_i coefficient alone should be presented as an evaluated consequence, not a new universal decoherence principle. R3 explicitly credits Yang for the covariance-controlled purity-loss framework. This resolves attribution wording, not the unresolved priority of individual XY coefficients or the combined-application novelty assessment.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C5Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C5
new secondary analysis of public records: The underlying experiment, shadows, charge-distribution access and broad QME observation are prior work. No equivalent report of the specified position-resolved depletion/accumulation plus jointly resampled end-block crossing comparison was identified. This is a secondary analysis delta with explicit missing end-case support; it does not establish that the improved estimator is experimentally superior. R3 marks omitted/large Fig. 3 uncertainties while retaining the full-sample estimates and numerical inputs; it creates no new data claim.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C6Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C6
specific numerical control result: No equivalent same-field reversal of the specified end/central crossing order was identified. The delta is the ideal 12-ion calculation at fixed blocks and tilt pairs: h_i=-r_i changes 2.28/1.19 to 1.48/1.66 ms for 0.5pi/0.2pi; the second pair retains a positive delay. Generic field tuning and graph-Laplacian/row-sum compensation are established ideas. Hallam et al. tune a spatially uniform field and emergent symmetry in an XYZ model, a different result.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C7Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C7
conditional measurement-assisted method: The sector decomposition and Gaussian/coherence machinery are established or elementary. No equivalent operational recipe combining time- and tilt-resolved measured populations with a same-Hamiltonian three-tilt single-site calibration and this empirical conversion was identified. The delta is the conditional estimator and its tested implementation, not a Hamiltonian-only predictor or a new general sector-dephasing explanation. R3 correctly limits r>1 to rejecting a Gaussian phase-covariance interpretation; it does not uniquely diagnose transport.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C8Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C8
candidate-specific benchmark evidence: Supporting computational evidence for the frozen method, rather than a free-standing priority claim. No external source reports this exact scoped pool and error statistic. The 719 evaluations are dependent selected evaluations, with the alpha=1.5 end failure retained. Provenance classification passes; no generalization guarantee or independent new experimental evidence is implied. R3 names the actual sampled chains/models explicitly; it does not enlarge or independently reproduce the 719-case evidence.
Open →literature · RO-2026-0009:literature:C9Literature audit for RO-2026-0009:C9
model-specific simulation/application: Supporting simulation delta for reconstructed 51-ion Hamiltonians and specified blocks/tilts. Prior 51-ion sensing and long-range-QME TDVP machinery are credited. No equivalent publication of these exact reconstructed-model crossings and estimator comparisons was identified. This remains a classical model prediction with reconstruction sensitivity, not a measured 51-ion multi-tilt QME or a new simulation algorithm.
Open →program · PRG-mathematical-physicsMathematical Physics
Exact structures, constructive proofs, and reusable obstructions at the mathematics–physics boundary.
Open →program · PRG-quantum-informationQuantum Information
Sharp resource thresholds for extracting quantum information through measurement, copies, coherence, and computation.
Open →program · PRG-quantum-thermodynamicsQuantum Thermodynamics
Operational thermodynamics built from accessible quantum data, with clear limits on what can be inferred.
Open →program · PRG-stochastic-thermodynamicsStochastic Thermodynamics
Exact and experimentally grounded laws for fluctuating heat, work, entropy production, control, and engines in classical mesoscopic systems.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0001Few-Outcome Readout of Quantum-Fisher-Optimal Measurements: Sharp Bounds and Coherent-Synthesis Hardness
A quantum-Fisher-optimal measurement may resolve exponentially many eigenvectors even when its information-bearing score needs only a small outcome alphabet. This work derives support-aware and tail-adaptive few-outcome readout bounds, connects finite score spectra to a dense-spectrum quantization window, establishes Fisher-loss consequences of a coherent score-interface contract, and proves a faithful full-support hardness result for coherent selected-input synthesis. Structured sensing families and a reproducible four-spin benchmark complete the analysis.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0003Two-Copy Onset of Strict Superadditivity for Measured Relative Entropy
For faithful finite-dimensional state pairs, globally optimized measured relative entropy is additive at any fixed copy number n >= 2 exactly when the states commute. This Letter proves the criterion through an explicit phase-optimized two-copy ascent direction, separates coherent collective access from the known fresh-copy classical-feed-forward bound, gives a faithful qubit construction, and states a thermodynamic corollary only for the Gibbs-prepared isolated unitary-drive setting.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0004Minimum Bath Dimension for Qutrit Cooling Maps
At low temperature, cooling maps and thermal operations have identical transition power for a two-level system. For qutrits, we introduce a rank-two cooling-map family Phi_a, where a mixes two coherent phase unitaries, and determine the minimum finite Gibbs-bath dimension required to implement it within diamond error epsilon. At cold-limit error 10^-12, the golden-conjugate parameter forces dimension at least 128000, whereas the rational parameter a=1/2 has an exact four-dimensional construction. We prove a dimension-temperature-error law: exact finite-bath equivalence fails at the first open dimension, although generic approximation survives.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0005Stochastic Thermodynamics of Highly Underdamped Homogeneous Hamiltonian Systems
A systematic tutorial and semi-review develops a density-of-states-consistent stochastic thermodynamics for highly underdamped Hamiltonian systems from established Kramers energy diffusion. Positive homogeneous Hamiltonians organize exact energy, heat, entropy-production, work, protocol, cycle, and interacting graph-cage results by effective degrees of freedom and the relaxation rate.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0007An Exact Product Limit on Collective Quantum Readout
Can two independently prepared quantum systems require a joint measurement to read a fluctuation with the least possible variance? We prepare two copies of either candidate state. A measured Pearson quantity compares the outcome distributions of the two candidate preparations. Fully-PPT detectors include measurements made separately on each copy. The class maximum is the product of the one-copy optima, attained by measuring an optimal score on each copy. Noncommuting states allow an unrestricted joint measurement to do strictly better. We then fix a state-calibrated collective score as a theoretical witness. Its spectral readout adds no variance, but every unbiased fully-PPT readout must add some. A moment inequality strengthens this necessary bound; the exact restricted minimum remains unknown. Driven and equilibrium models illustrate the bounds without a device demonstration. The results concern calibrated scores, not work readout, detector energy cost, or local thermometry.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0008Exponentially Accurate Work Extraction by Swapping Detuned Bosonic Modes
A temperature imbalance between two thermal oscillators can yield exponentially little work, even under arbitrary unitary control. We determine when frequency detuning makes a simple mode swap nearly optimal, by bounding the entire extra work available beyond Gaussian operations. With detuning proportional to the temperature bias near equilibrium, this absolute improvement is exponentially small in the inverse bias. The bound separates exponentially weak extraction at resonance from a detuning window with quadratic work, where the swap captures the leading resource. In this limit, within that window, the accessible fraction of the energy excess above a Gibbs state of equal entropy follows a temperature-independent parabola in detuning normalized by the bias. Inside the window, any fixed fraction below 100% of the leading work can be extracted with an occupation cutoff independent of the bias. The finite bound determines when more general control offers negligible additional work.
Open →research object · RO-2026-0009Dephasing Threshold and Charge Transport in the Quantum Mpemba Effect
A tilted ferromagnet that breaks a U(1) symmetry more strongly can restore it faster in a subsystem: the quantum Mpemba effect. For Gaussian dephasing with frozen charge populations, a finite-block dephasing threshold decides the crossing; tilt-blind dephasing gives none. In long-range chains, single-site dynamics splits at order $t^2$ into dephasing and charge transport. Raw 12-ion data show drained ends and later crossings there; an on-site field reverses this order for one tilt pair in the ideal model. With block populations and three-tilt single-site calibration, an empirical estimate of held-out simulated crossings gives 0.06 ms pooled median error across 719 dependent evaluations for the sampled 12-ion chains with interaction exponents 0.5 and 1, their coupling perturbations, and two reconstructed 51-ion models.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-001RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-001
The proven Fisher-loss statement concerns an exact PVM of the Hermitian approximation, not the delivered finite-precision instrument. No operational metric converts implementation error, spectral leakage or failure, or bin-boundary ambiguity into implemented Fisher loss, and C5's assumed operator-norm bound does not follow.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-002RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-002
The explicit full-cost assumption conflicts with a partial proxy that leaves solver cost unresolved and omits composed square-root, Sylvester, access, precision-allocation, and amplification costs.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-003RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-003
Polynomial sample cost in the beta-equals-c-over-n window lacks a uniform nonasymptotic quantum-Fisher-information lower bound with a controlled remainder.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-004RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-004
Direct antecedents contain consecutive spectral binning, quantization optimization, within-bin variance loss, general SLD clustering, and Wasserstein quantization stability; the current originality boundary is not yet reliable.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-005RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-005
The artificial hardness construction, classically structured scalable sensor, and four-spin example do not yet bridge into the broad physical impact asserted by the candidate framing.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-006RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-006
The isolated regeneration supports C7, but the official validator does not recompute the advertised quantities and the pinned clean-room contract remains incomplete.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-007RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-007
Optimized product measurement can imply a certified optimum, while the supported statement is the best product PVM found by the archived heuristic search.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-008RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-008
The C1 computation path misses the direct diameter tests, figure and table counts conflict with generated data, and the Sheng dependency metadata require current digest binding.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R1-009RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R1-009
The companion result is accessible at a pinned commit and supports the imported specialization, but lacks its planned stable scholarly identifier; the reproducibility DOI is also absent.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R2-001RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R2-001
The integrated toolkit did not meet the separate exceptional broad-impact threshold.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R2-002RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R2-002
The score interface was a contract rather than a primitive-to-error and end-to-end cost theorem.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R2-003RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R2-003
The supplement named absent build and checksum files, and claim paths were not fully rebound to the candidate.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R2-004RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R2-004
Anteceded identities and imported geometry required tighter, claim-level attribution.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R2-005RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R2-005
Stable identifiers and inspected isolated-container evidence were absent.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R3-001RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R3-001
The score-intertwining Fisher-loss identity is correct under the declared isometry contract.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R3-002RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R3-002
The reconstructed-signal inequality is a valid consequence of the accepted interface assumptions.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R3-003RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R3-003
The full-support embedding and metrological promises support the restricted coherent selected-input hardness statement.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R3-004RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R3-004
All seven claims are valid, package-local, resolvable, and bound to the accepted archive.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R3-005RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R3-005
Fresh complete and smoke runs passed all 34 declared checks in all 12 families.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0001:review:F-R3-006RO-2026-0001 review finding F-R3-006
The exact contiguous-bin optima reproduce and the product value is correctly limited to a heuristic-search baseline.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R1-300RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R1-300
The Letter omitted the closest embedded prior phase-adjusted projective-variation calculus.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R1-301RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R1-301
The role migration was unattested and the candidate lacked a complete digest-bound provenance and review surface.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R1-302RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R1-302
Historical backend-snapshot material diluted the analytic Letter.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R1-303RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R1-303
Analytic and archived backend workflows had incompatible locks but a shared route.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R1-304RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R1-304
Some labels used exact language for a recovered stationary candidate without a global objective-gap enclosure.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R2-300RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R2-300
Environment locks, routed commands, and renderer provenance were internally inconsistent.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R2-300RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R2-300
Final referee disagreement over whether backend regeneration evidence was complete.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R2-301RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R2-301
Canonical data and PDF paths were inconsistent across provenance and build surfaces.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R2-301RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R2-301
Verify the repaired paths and document route against exact r04.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R2-302RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R2-302
Embedded pre-freeze status was inaccurately described as controlling post-freeze state.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0003:review:F-R2-302RO-2026-0003 review finding F-R2-302
Decide whether redundant embedded identifiers and a stale prior-round tuple block private scientific GO.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0004:review:F-R1-001RO-2026-0004 review finding F-R1-001
The finite-bath, exact-energy-conservation model is narrow, and its operational inference must not be presented as model-independent thermodynamics.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0004:review:F-R1-002RO-2026-0004 review finding F-R1-002
Irrational approximation claims and displayed bath dimensions require exact, independently checkable arithmetic artifacts.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0005:review:F-R1-001RO-2026-0005 review finding F-R1-001
The general free-energy rate omitted -S dot T and the irreversible-work decomposition was not restricted to fixed temperature.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0005:review:F-R1-002RO-2026-0005 review finding F-R1-002
Gamma-difference priority, smooth-control domain, arbitrary-q versus quartic scope, and the hard-sphere convergence boundary required narrowing.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0005:review:F-R1-003RO-2026-0005 review finding F-R1-003
The source archive contained internal material and lacked a correct final ten-figure accessibility map.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0005:review:F-R2-001RO-2026-0005 review finding F-R2-001
A conventional journal may require a natural-person author able to assume formal authorship duties.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0005:review:F-R2-002RO-2026-0005 review finding F-R2-002
The PDFs are not PDF-UA tagged.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R1-001RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R1-001
State-calibrated collective score lacked a clear independent readout purpose.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R1-002RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R1-002
The exact prescribed-score PPT minimum and feasible receiver gap were not adjacent to application claims.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R1-003RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R1-003
Closest restricted-Renyi work needed objective, product-input, and cut comparison.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R1-004RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R1-004
The rare product-receiver outcome made a population curve inadequate as a finite-shot certificate.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R1-005RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R1-005
AI author byline and disclosure would require a different actual APS process.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R2-001RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R2-001
The Rippchen sentence compressed a general result into its special-family examples.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R2-002RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R2-002
The second model repeated receiver and bound descriptions in a four-page Letter.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0007:review:F-R2-003RO-2026-0007 review finding F-R2-003
Actual APS submission requires separate compliant authorship, AI-use disclosure and data availability.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0008:review:F-R5-001RO-2026-0008 review finding F-R5-001
The ideal two-mode thermal/Gaussian setting and coordinated near-equilibrium limit restrict breadth. Robustness to preparation error, anharmonicity, growing arrays, tuning cost and dynamical control cost are not established. A compact significance sentence was suggested optionally.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0008:review:F-R5-002RO-2026-0008 review finding F-R5-002
Optional addition of near-equilibrium wording to the title would make the asymptotic setting visible immediately.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0008:review:F-R5-003RO-2026-0008 review finding F-R5-003
Optionally recall near the first remainder formula that the interior exponent is an upper estimate; matching rates are proved only outside the window.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0008:review:F-R5-004RO-2026-0008 review finding F-R5-004
A generic Work fraction ordinate would cover both Gaussian swap curves and unrestricted-work markers; the existing legend and caption already distinguish them.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0008:review:F-R5-005RO-2026-0008 review finding F-R5-005
A pinpoint citation could clarify that the plotted gray allowance is the entropy-only relaxation and does not evaluate every bound containing passive-state information in Ref. 22.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-001RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-001
Make trajectory attainment explicit in Proposition 2 and the Letter. The proof establishes a parameter-space equality root; continuous growth from zero can saturate below it and does not alone ensure a finite-time equality. No blocking defect in the root-existence proof was found.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-002RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-002
Scope novelty to the finite-block theorem and explicit XY transport-normalization/control combination. Reconcile the Supplement's new-characterization language with the known classification of C1, and credit the general initial purity-loss covariance framework underlying the isolated normalized C4 coefficient.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-003RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-003
Describe the actual systems included in the 719-evaluation pool instead of literally classifying every included reconstructed coupling profile as decaying as 1/r or slower. Preserve the reported failed stratum and conditional empirical scope. The numerical aggregate itself passed.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-101RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-101
Non-blocking reproducibility correction: the advertised prl/RUN.md and prl/TRACEABILITY.md are absent. Deposit executable environment, working-directory, raw-archive-placement and data-to-output instructions, or correct the availability statement to point to actual deposited equivalents.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-102RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-102
Non-blocking supplementary interpretation correction: an extracted effective pair correlation r>1 rules out a Gaussian phase covariance under the stated assumptions but does not by itself identify magnon exchange. Present exchange as a model-supported explanation and acknowledge non-Gaussian phase statistics and estimator effects.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-103RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-103
Non-blocking presentation correction: identify the triangle points in Fig. 3(c) whose errors are undefined or suppressed by the 0.8 ms plotting cutoff. Explain the omission and mark them distinctly rather than allowing absent bars to imply negligible uncertainty.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-104RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-104
Two unqualified zero-limit phrases could include the density ratio, whose limit is one.
Open →review finding · RO-2026-0009:review:F-R1-105RO-2026-0009 review finding F-R1-105
The leading inline density-matrix expansion conjugated the ket-vacuum coefficient incorrectly.
Open →story · STORY-2026-0001Why a Quantum Detector Might Need Fewer Answers
Quantum sensors are prized for exquisite sensitivity. But their mathematically perfect measurements can demand a bewildering number of outcomes. A new analysis asks which distinctions matter—and why shrinking the display does not simplify the machine behind it.
Open →story · STORY-2026-0002When Two Quantum Copies Are Worth More Than Twice One
For decades, physicists knew that joint measurements could recover quantum evidence that separate readouts miss. A new Pudim Letter identifies the universal turning point for full-rank states: two copies.
Open →story · STORY-2026-0003How a Qutrit Can Force a 128,000-Dimensional Heat Bath
A three-level quantum system sounds small. Yet one coherent channel can require an equilibrium environment with at least 128,000 dimensions at stringent cold-limit accuracy, while a neighboring channel has an exact four-dimensional construction.
Open →story · STORY-2026-0004A Heat Engine That Runs by Rewiring a Network
In a solvable many-particle model, adding and removing one bond produces exact work and entropy laws controlled by a single network distance—then closes into a two-temperature engine.
Open →story · STORY-2026-0006When a Quantum Swap Is Hard to Improve
A finite bound shows when a simple swap between two thermal oscillators captures nearly all available work, leaving an exponentially small reward for more elaborate control.
Open →story · STORY-2026-0007Changing the Order of a Quantum Race
A Pudim Letter separates fading spin alignment from moving excitations, helping interpret a boundary delay and predicting its reversal for one pair of preparations in an ideal model.
Open →